Lang Nicolas, Siebner Hartwig R, Chadaide Zoltan, Boros Klara, Nitsche Michael A, Rothwell John C, Paulus Walter, Antal Andrea
Department of Clinical Neurophysiology, Georg-August University, Göttingen, Germany.
Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci. 2007 Dec;48(12):5782-7. doi: 10.1167/iovs.07-0706.
In the motor cortex (M1), transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) can effectively prime excitability changes that are evoked by a subsequent train of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS). The authors examined whether tDCS can also prime the cortical response to rTMS in the human visual cortex.
In nine healthy subjects, the authors applied tDCS (10 minutes; +/-1 mA) to the occipital cortex. After tDCS, they applied a 20-second train of 5 Hz rTMS at 90% of phosphene threshold (PT) intensity. A similar rTMS protocol had previously demonstrated a strong priming effect of tDCS on rTMS-induced excitability changes in M1. PTs were determined with single-pulse TMS before and immediately after tDCS and twice after rTMS.
Anodal tDCS led to a transient decrease in PT, and subsequent 5 Hz rTMS induced an earlier return of the PT back to baseline. Cathodal tDCS produced a short-lasting increase in PT, but 5 Hz rTMS did not influence the tDCS-induced increase in PT. In a control experiment on four subjects, a 20-second train of occipital 5 Hz rTMS left the PT unchanged, whereas a 60-second train produced a similar decrease in PT as anodal tDCS alone.
Compared with previous work on the M1, tDCS and rTMS of the visual cortex only produce short-lasting changes in cortical excitability. Moreover, the priming effects of tDCS on subsequent rTMS conditioning are relatively modest. These discrepancies point to substantial differences in the modifiability of human motor and visual cortex.
在运动皮层(M1)中,经颅直流电刺激(tDCS)可有效引发由随后的重复经颅磁刺激(rTMS)序列所诱发的兴奋性变化。作者研究了tDCS是否也能引发人类视觉皮层对rTMS的皮层反应。
在9名健康受试者中,作者将tDCS(10分钟;±1毫安)施加于枕叶皮层。tDCS之后,他们以光幻视阈值(PT)强度的90%施加20秒的5赫兹rTMS序列。此前类似的rTMS方案已证明tDCS对rTMS诱导的M1兴奋性变化有强烈的引发效应。在tDCS之前和之后立即以及rTMS之后两次,用单脉冲TMS测定PT。
阳极tDCS导致PT短暂下降,随后的5赫兹rTMS诱导PT更早恢复到基线。阴极tDCS使PT产生短暂升高,但5赫兹rTMS并未影响tDCS诱导的PT升高。在对4名受试者的对照实验中,20秒的枕叶5赫兹rTMS序列使PT保持不变,而60秒的序列产生了与单独阳极tDCS类似的PT下降。
与之前关于M1的研究相比,视觉皮层的tDCS和rTMS仅产生皮层兴奋性的短暂变化。此外,tDCS对随后rTMS条件作用的引发效应相对较小。这些差异表明人类运动皮层和视觉皮层在可修饰性方面存在显著差异。