Hutmacher Matthew M, Krishnaswami Sriram, Kowalski Kenneth G
Pharmacometrics Group, Pfizer Corporation, Ann Arbor, MI, USA.
J Pharmacokinet Pharmacodyn. 2008 Apr;35(2):139-57. doi: 10.1007/s10928-007-9080-2. Epub 2007 Dec 6.
Currently, no general methods have been developed to relate pharmacologically based models, such as indirect response models, to discrete or ordered categorical data. We propose the use of an unobservable latent variable (LV), through which indirect response models can be linked with drug exposure. The resulting indirect latent variable response model (ILVRM) is demonstrated using a case study of a JAK3 inhibitor, which was administered to patients in a rheumatoid arthritis (RA) study. The clinical endpoint for signs and symptoms in RA is the American College of Rheumatology response criterion of 20%--a binary response variable. In this case study, four exposure-response models, which have different pharmacological interpretations, were constructed and fitted using the ILVRM method. Specifically, two indirect response models, an effect compartment model, and a model which assumes instantaneous (direct) drug action were assessed and compared for their ability to predict the response data. In general, different model interpretations can influence drug inference, such as time to drug effect onset, as well as affect extrapolations of responses to untested experimental conditions, and the underlying pharmacology that operates to generate key response features does not change because the response was measured discretely. Consideration of these model interpretations can impact future study designs and ultimately provide greater insight into drug development strategies.
目前,尚未开发出将基于药理学的模型(如间接响应模型)与离散或有序分类数据相关联的通用方法。我们建议使用一个不可观测的潜在变量(LV),通过它可以将间接响应模型与药物暴露联系起来。通过类风湿性关节炎(RA)研究中对患者施用JAK3抑制剂的案例研究,展示了由此产生的间接潜在变量响应模型(ILVRM)。RA中体征和症状的临床终点是美国风湿病学会20%的反应标准——一个二元反应变量。在这个案例研究中,使用ILVRM方法构建并拟合了四个具有不同药理学解释的暴露-反应模型。具体而言,评估并比较了两个间接响应模型、一个效应室模型和一个假设药物瞬时(直接)作用的模型预测反应数据的能力。一般来说,不同的模型解释会影响药物推断,如药物起效时间,也会影响对未测试实验条件下反应的外推,并且产生关键反应特征的潜在药理学不会因为反应是离散测量而改变。考虑这些模型解释会影响未来的研究设计,并最终为药物开发策略提供更深入的见解。