van Beurden A, de Ruijter S H W, Schmitz R F
Groene Hart Ziekenhuis, afd. Heelkunde, Huispost B 2.84, Postbus 0098, 2800 BB Gouda.
Ned Tijdschr Geneeskd. 2007 Nov 17;151(46):2570-3.
To determine whether the 1993 guideline from the Dutch Institute for Healthcare Improvement (CBO) is followed in the Southwest region of the Netherlands. The guideline states that preoperative hair removal serves no purpose in preventing wound infection.
Inventory.
All surgical short-stay departments in the Southwest region of The Netherlands received a structured questionnaire on their management of preoperative hair removal. Questions included whether or not they had a hair removing protocol, which methods they used for removing hair and the timeframe within which preoperative hair removal usually was carried out.
The response was 100% (24/24). The majority of surgical short-stay departments did practice preoperative hair removal (88%). Less than half of the hospitals use a hair removal protocol. Hair clippers were used for preoperative hair removal in most hospitals (86%) and in 71% the procedure was carried out within 2 hours of the planned operation and mostly by nursing staff (71%). No difference was found in hair removal management in hospitals with or without a protocol.
Despite the existence of a published guideline that states that preoperative hair removal serves no purpose in preventing wound infection, the majority of hospitals in the Southwest region of the Netherlands do still carry out the practice as a routine action. The policy of hair removal management appears to depend on subjective feelings of individual surgeons. The existence ofan evidenced-based guideline does not appear to have much effect on this management.
确定荷兰西南部地区是否遵循荷兰医疗保健改善研究所(CBO)1993年发布的指南。该指南指出,术前去除毛发对预防伤口感染并无作用。
清查。
向荷兰西南部地区所有外科短期住院科室发放了一份关于术前毛发去除管理的结构化问卷。问题包括他们是否有毛发去除方案、使用何种方法去除毛发以及术前毛发去除通常在哪个时间段进行。
回复率为100%(24/24)。大多数外科短期住院科室确实进行术前毛发去除(88%)。不到一半的医院使用毛发去除方案。大多数医院(86%)使用理发器进行术前毛发去除,71%的医院在计划手术的2小时内进行该操作,且大多由护理人员执行(71%)。有无方案的医院在毛发去除管理方面未发现差异。
尽管有已发布的指南表明术前去除毛发对预防伤口感染并无作用,但荷兰西南部地区的大多数医院仍将其作为常规操作。毛发去除管理政策似乎取决于个别外科医生的主观感受。基于证据的指南的存在似乎对这种管理没有太大影响。