Pitts N B, Hamood S S, Longbottom C, Rimmer P A
Department of Dental Health, Dental School, University of Dundee, Scotland.
Dentomaxillofac Radiol. 1991 Aug;20(3):121-6. doi: 10.1259/dmfr.20.3.1807994.
The use of film-holding, beam-aiming devices have been shown to have a number of potential advantages in achieving high quality bitweing radiographs, however, little information is available about their acceptability to children. The aims of this study were: (1) to determine the level of acceptance of a conventional type of film positioner to child patients in a general practice setting in Scotland and (2) to compare the acceptability to children of bitewing procedures using: the freehand technique, a 'Rinn' positioner and a new positioner, the 'HPL' device. In the general practice group, following modifications made during a pilot study, 211 children aged 3-15 years were offered a bitewing examination with a modified Rinn positioner at recall. The overall acceptance rate of the bitewing procedure was 82.5%. All 10 children aged 3-4 years offered bitewings refused, while 77 (69%) of subjects aged 5-9 years accepted, as did all the 89 children aged 10-15 years. In the comparison of acceptability investigation, three groups of 30 children aged 6-15 years requiring bitewing radiographs were selected at random. Each group had a different bitewing technique carried out by the same operator. The children's acceptance of all three techniques was high (87-97%) and no statistically significant difference was found between the acceptability of the freehand method and those involving film positioning devices. Although the unmodified Rinn design suffered from a number of problems, the modified version was found to be acceptable by many children.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
已证明,使用胶片固定、射线束瞄准装置在获取高质量咬合翼片X线片方面具有许多潜在优势,然而,关于儿童对其接受程度的信息却很少。本研究的目的是:(1)确定在苏格兰的一家普通诊所中,儿童患者对传统类型胶片定位器的接受程度;(2)比较儿童对使用徒手技术、“Rinn”定位器和一种新型定位器“HPL”装置进行咬合翼片检查的接受程度。在普通诊所组中,经过初步研究中的改进后,在复诊时为211名3至15岁的儿童提供了使用改良Rinn定位器的咬合翼片检查。咬合翼片检查的总体接受率为82.5%。所有10名接受咬合翼片检查的3至4岁儿童都拒绝了,而5至9岁的受试者中有77名(69%)接受了,10至15岁的89名儿童也都接受了。在可接受性调查的比较中,随机选择了三组需要进行咬合翼片X线检查的6至15岁儿童,每组30名。每组由同一名操作人员采用不同的咬合翼片技术。儿童对所有三种技术的接受度都很高(87 - 97%),徒手方法与涉及胶片定位装置的方法在可接受性方面未发现统计学上的显著差异。尽管未改良的Rinn设计存在一些问题,但改良版被许多儿童认为是可以接受的。(摘要截选至250字)