Li Jian-Ping, Zhang Hui, Cai Jun, Gan Xia-Man, Fan Fang-Ling, He Pei-Da
Xuhui District Central Hospital, Shanghai 200031, China.
Zhongguo Zhen Jiu. 2007 Nov;27(11):804-6.
To use distinctive water-medicine cup therapy for treatment of cervical spondylopathy of cervical type as a sample to provide a more effective cupping method for clinic.
One hundred and forty cases were randomly divided into a medicine cup group (n = 47), a water cup group (n = 47) and a empty cup group (n = 46). The medicine cup group were treated by cupping therapy with a self-made medicine cup with 45 degrees C Chinese herb solution; the water cup group were treated with a cup with 45 degrees C water, and the empty cup group with a cup with nothing. Clinical symptoms and signs were observed for comparison of therapeutic effects.
Clinically cured was 39 cases, and markedly effective was 8 cases in the medicine cup group; 20 cases were clinically cured, 22 cases were markedly effective and 5 cases were effective in the water cup group; 12 cases were clinically cured, 19 cases were markedly effective and 15 cases were effective in the empty cup group. There were significant differences in the ratio of cases of different therapeutic effects and the difference of pain score before and after treatment between the medicine cup group and the water cup group (P < 0.05), between the water cup group and the empty cup group (P < 0.05), and between the medicine cup group and the empty cup group (P < 0.01).
The therapeutic effect of the distinctive medicine cup is better than the water cup group, and the water cup group is better than the empty cup group.
以特色水药罐疗法治疗颈型颈椎病为例,为临床提供一种更有效的拔罐方法。
将140例患者随机分为药罐组(n = 47)、水杯组(n = 47)和空罐组(n = 46)。药罐组采用自制药罐,内盛45℃中药溶液进行拔罐治疗;水杯组采用盛45℃水的杯子进行治疗,空罐组采用空杯子进行治疗。观察临床症状和体征,比较治疗效果。
药罐组临床治愈39例,显效8例;水杯组临床治愈20例,显效22例,有效5例;空罐组临床治愈12例,显效19例,有效15例。药罐组与水杯组不同治疗效果病例比例及治疗前后疼痛评分差值有显著差异(P < 0.05),水杯组与空罐组有显著差异(P < 0.05),药罐组与空罐组有极显著差异(P < 0.01)。
特色药罐的治疗效果优于水杯组,水杯组优于空罐组。