Muula Adamson S, Chipeta John, Siziya Seter, Rudatsikira Emmanuel, Mataya Ronald H, Kataika Edward
Department of Community Health, University of Malawi, College of Medicine, Blantyre, Malawi.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2007 Dec 19;7:208. doi: 10.1186/1472-6963-7-208.
Twelve percent of the adult population in Malawi is estimated to be HIV infected. About 15% to 20% of these are in need of life saving antiretroviral therapy. The country has a public sector-led antiretroviral treatment program both in the private and public health sectors. Estimation of the clinical human resources needs is required to inform the planning and distribution of health professionals.
We obtained data on the total number of patients on highly active antiretroviral treatment program from the Malawi National AIDS Commission and Ministry of Health, HIV Unit, and the number of registered health professionals from the relevant regulatory bodies. We also estimated number of health professionals required to deliver highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART) using estimates of human resources from the literature. We also obtained data from the Ministry of Health on the actual number of nurses, clinical officers and medical doctors providing services in HAART clinics. We then made comparisons between the human resources situation on the ground and the theoretical estimates based on explicit assumptions.
There were 610 clinicians (396 clinical officers and 214 physicians), 44 pharmacists and 98 pharmacy technicians and 7264 nurses registered in Malawi. At the end of March 2007 there were 85 clinical officer and physician full-time equivalents (FTEs) and 91 nurse FTEs providing HAART to 95,674 patients. The human resources used for the delivery of HAART comprised 13.9% of all clinical officers and physicians and 1.1% of all nurses. Using the estimated numbers of health professionals from the literature required 15.7-31.4% of all physicians and clinical officers, 66.5-199.3% of all pharmacists and pharmacy technicians and 2.6 to 9.2% of all the available nurses. To provide HAART to all the 170,000 HIV infected persons estimated as clinically eligible would require 4.7% to 16.4% of the total number of nurses, 118.1% to 354.2% of all the available pharmacists and pharmacy technicians and 27.9% to 55.7% of all clinical officers and physicians. The actual number of health professionals working in the delivery of HAART in the clinics represented 44% to 88.8% (for clinical officers and medical doctors) and 13.6% and 47.6% (for nurses), of what would have been needed based on the literature estimation.
HAART provision is a labour intensive exercise. Although these data are insufficient to determine whether HAART scale-up has resulted in the weakening or strengthening of the health systems in Malawi, the human resources requirements for HAART scale-up are significant. Malawi is using far less human resources than would be estimated based on the literature from other settings. The impact of HAART scale-up on the overall delivery of health services should be assessed.
据估计,马拉维12%的成年人口感染了艾滋病毒。其中约15%至20%的人需要挽救生命的抗逆转录病毒疗法。该国在私营和公共卫生部门都有一个由公共部门主导的抗逆转录病毒治疗项目。需要估计临床人力资源需求,以便为卫生专业人员的规划和分配提供依据。
我们从马拉维国家艾滋病委员会、卫生部艾滋病毒部门获取了接受高效抗逆转录病毒治疗项目的患者总数数据,以及从相关监管机构获取了注册卫生专业人员的数量。我们还利用文献中的人力资源估计数,估算了提供高效抗逆转录病毒疗法(HAART)所需的卫生专业人员数量。我们还从卫生部获取了在HAART诊所提供服务的护士、临床干事和医生的实际人数数据。然后,我们将实际的人力资源状况与基于明确假设的理论估计数进行了比较。
马拉维有610名临床医生(396名临床干事和214名医生)、44名药剂师、98名药房技术员和7264名护士注册。2007年3月底,有85名临床干事和医生全职当量(FTE)以及91名护士FTE为95674名患者提供HAART。用于提供HAART的人力资源占所有临床干事和医生的13.9%,占所有护士的1.1%。根据文献估计的卫生专业人员数量,需要所有医生和临床干事的15.7%至31.4%、所有药剂师和药房技术员的66.5%至199.3%以及所有现有护士的2.6%至9.2%。要为所有估计符合临床条件的170000名艾滋病毒感染者提供HAART,将需要占护士总数4.7%至16.4%、所有现有药剂师和药房技术员的118.1%至354.2%以及所有临床干事和医生的27.9%至55.7%。在诊所提供HAART服务的卫生专业人员的实际数量占文献估计所需数量的44%至88.8%(临床干事和医生)以及13.6%和47.6%(护士)。
提供HAART是一项劳动密集型工作。虽然这些数据不足以确定扩大HAART规模是否导致马拉维卫生系统的削弱或加强,但扩大HAART规模所需的人力资源数量巨大。马拉维使用的人力资源远低于根据其他地区文献估计的数量。应评估扩大HAART规模对卫生服务总体提供的影响。