Bae Sook Young, Kwon Jung Ah, Kim Jang Su, Yoon Soo Young, Lee Chang Kyu, Lee Kap No, Kim Dae Won, Min Won Ki, Cha Young Joo, Chae Seok Lae, Hwang Yoo Sung
Department of Laboratory Medicine, College of Medicine, Korea University, Seoul, Korea.
Korean J Lab Med. 2007 Apr;27(2):143-50. doi: 10.3343/kjlm.2007.27.2.143.
A questionnaire survey was performed to perceive the problem of the current medical insurance reimbursement system for laboratory tests referred to independent medical laboratories; then, we intended to find a way to improve the reimbursement system.
Questionnaires were distributed to 220 independent medical laboratories and 700 laboratory physicians from July through October 2005. Frequency analysis was used to analyse the replies from 109 respondents to 25 questionnaire items regarding the current medical insurance reimbursement system for referral tests, problems with the system, and suggestions for the improvement of the system.
Among the 109 respondents to this survey, 49 (45.8%) considered the current reimbursement system to be unsatisfactory, while only 16 (15.0%) answered satisfactory. The problem was that the referral clinics-not the laboratories that performed the tests--would first receive their reimbursement for the laboratory tests from Health Insurance Review Agency (HIRA) and then give a portion of the laboratory test fees to the independent medical laboratories after the deduction of administrative fees. They (62.5% of the respondents) would prefer a separated reimbursement system by which the referral clinic-as well as the independent medical laboratory-would receive their reimbursement directly from HIRA through an Electronic Data Interchange (EDI) system. In this new system, 34% of the respondents expected the quality of the laboratory tests to be improved; however, 41.6% answered that the income of the referral clinic is expected to decrease.
For the improvement of the medical insurance reimbursement system, the administrative fee for the referral clinic and the test fee for the independent medical laboratory should be reimbursed directly to the respective organizations. These changes could be made possible with the proper analysis of medical costs and the development of an effective EDI reimbursement system.
开展问卷调查以了解当前针对独立医学实验室检验项目的医疗保险报销系统存在的问题;随后,我们试图找到改进该报销系统的方法。
在2005年7月至10月期间,向220家独立医学实验室和700名检验医师发放问卷。采用频率分析方法,对109名受访者针对25项问卷内容的回复进行分析,这些内容涉及当前转诊检验的医疗保险报销系统、该系统存在的问题以及改进该系统 的建议。
在本次调查的109名受访者中,49人(45.8%)认为当前报销系统不尽人意,而只有16人(15.0%)给出了满意的答复。问题在于,转诊诊所(而非进行检验的实验室)会首先从健康保险审查机构(HIRA)获得实验室检验的报销款,然后在扣除管理费后,将一部分实验室检验费用支付给独立医学实验室。他们(62.5%的受访者)更倾向于一种分开报销系统,即转诊诊所和独立医学实验室都通过电子数据交换(EDI)系统直接从HIRA获得报销款。在这个新系统中,34%的受访者预计实验室检验质量会得到提高;然而,41.6%的受访者回答转诊诊所的收入预计会减少。
为改进医疗保险报销系统,应将转诊诊所的管理费和独立医学实验室的检验费直接报销给各自的机构。通过对医疗成本进行适当分析并开发有效的EDI报销系统,这些改变将成为可能。