Rubin G James, Cleare Anthony J, Wessely Simon
King's College London, Institute of Psychiatry, London, United Kingdom.
J Psychosom Res. 2008 Jan;64(1):1-9; discussion 11-2. doi: 10.1016/j.jpsychores.2007.05.006. Epub 2007 Aug 1.
Some people report symptoms associated with mobile phone use. A minority also report "electrosensitivity," experiencing symptoms following exposure to other electrical devices. Research suggests that electromagnetic fields do not trigger these symptoms. In this study, we examined the differences between these two "sensitive" groups and healthy controls.
Fifty-two people who reported sensitivity to mobile phones, 19 people who reported sensitivity to mobile phones and "electrosensitivity," and 60 nonsensitive controls completed a questionnaire assessing the following: primary reason for using a mobile phone, psychological health, symptoms of depression, modern health worries (MHW), general health status, symptom severity, and the presence of other medically unexplained syndromes.
Perceived sensitivity was associated with an increased likelihood of using a mobile phone predominantly for work (3% of controls, 13% of those sensitive to mobile phones, and 21% of those reporting "electrosensitivity") and greater MHW concerning radiation [mean (S.D.) on a scale of 1-5: 2.0 (1.0), 2.7 (0.9), and 4.0 (0.8), respectively]. Participants who reported "electrosensitivity" also experienced greater depression, greater worries about tainted food and toxic interventions, worse general health on almost every measure, and a greater number of other medically unexplained syndromes compared to participants from the other two groups. No group differences were observed with regards to psychiatric cases.
The data illustrate that patients reporting "electrosensitivity" experience substantially worse health than either healthy individuals or people who report sensitivity to mobile phones but who do not adopt the label "electrosensitivity." Clinicians and researchers would be wise to pay greater attention to this subdivision.
一些人报告了与使用手机相关的症状。少数人还报告有“电磁敏感症”,即在接触其他电子设备后出现症状。研究表明,电磁场不会引发这些症状。在本研究中,我们考察了这两类“敏感”人群与健康对照组之间的差异。
52名自称对手机敏感的人、19名自称对手机和“电磁敏感症”敏感的人以及60名不敏感的对照组人员完成了一份问卷,该问卷评估以下内容:使用手机的主要原因、心理健康状况、抑郁症状、现代健康担忧(MHW)、总体健康状况、症状严重程度以及是否存在其他医学上无法解释的综合征。
感知到的敏感性与主要为工作而使用手机的可能性增加相关(对照组为3%,对手机敏感者为13%,报告有“电磁敏感症”者为21%),且对辐射的现代健康担忧更大[在1 - 5分的量表上,平均值(标准差)分别为:2.0(1.0)、2.7(0.9)和4.0(0.8)]。与其他两组参与者相比,报告有“电磁敏感症”的参与者还经历了更严重的抑郁、对受污染食物和有毒干预措施的更多担忧、几乎在各项指标上更差的总体健康状况以及更多其他医学上无法解释的综合征。在精神病例方面未观察到组间差异。
数据表明,报告有“电磁敏感症”的患者健康状况比健康个体或报告对手机敏感但未采用“电磁敏感症”这一标签的人要差得多。临床医生和研究人员最好更加关注这一细分群体。