Bjerre Bo, Thorsson Ulf
Traffic Medicine, Swedish Road Administration, Borlänge, Sweden.
Accid Anal Prev. 2008 Jan;40(1):267-73. doi: 10.1016/j.aap.2007.06.008. Epub 2007 Jul 20.
This study evaluates whether the completion of an alcohol ignition interlock programme (AIIP) results in lasting changes of the behaviour of drink drivers and whether such a programme is more effective than a conventional licence revocation followed by an approved doctor's assessment. In Sweden, DWI offenders can voluntarily select a 2-year AIIP in lieu of a 12-month licence revocation. The AIIP includes regular medical checkups designed to alter alcohol use habits. The study has a quasi-experimental design. Two groups of controls were used for comparisons. One with revoked licences, but with no comparable opportunity to participate in an AIIP and another with DWI offenders who had abstained from participating in the AIIP. Significantly more persons were relicensed in the AIIP group 2 and 3 years after the DWI offence. According to the AUDIT scores participants in the AIIP had lower rates of harmful alcohol consumption than compared controls 1 and 3 years after the DWI offence. In the post-treatment period the rate of DWI recidivism was about 60% and the rate of police-reported traffic accidents about 80% lower than during the 5-year period prior to the offence. Among controls being relicensed a similar reduction in traffic accidents, but not in DWI recidivism, was observed. In the post-treatment period sick leave, but not hospital-care utilisation, differed significantly between the groups.
The completion of an AIIP has favourable effects compared to conventional licence revocation and would appear to be a useful tool for attaining lasting changes in the alcohol and driving habits of DWI offenders.
本研究评估酒精点火联锁计划(AIIP)的完成是否会导致酒后驾车者行为的持久改变,以及该计划是否比传统的吊销驾照并随后由认可医生进行评估更有效。在瑞典,酒后驾车违法者可以自愿选择参加为期两年的AIIP,以代替为期12个月的吊销驾照处罚。AIIP包括旨在改变饮酒习惯的定期体检。该研究采用准实验设计。使用两组对照进行比较。一组是被吊销驾照,但没有可比的参加AIIP的机会,另一组是酒后驾车违法者中放弃参加AIIP的人。在酒后驾车违法2年和3年后,AIIP组中重新获得驾照的人数明显更多。根据酒精使用障碍识别测试(AUDIT)分数,在酒后驾车违法1年和3年后,AIIP的参与者有害饮酒率低于对照。在治疗后期间,酒后驾车累犯率比违法前5年期间降低了约60%,警方报告的交通事故率降低了约80%。在重新获得驾照的对照组中,观察到交通事故有类似的减少,但酒后驾车累犯率没有降低。在治疗后期间,两组之间病假情况存在显著差异,但住院护理利用率没有差异。
与传统的吊销驾照相比,完成AIIP有积极效果,似乎是实现酒后驾车违法者饮酒和驾驶习惯持久改变的有用工具。