Freed J R, Block L E
Section of Public Health Dentistry, School of Dentistry, University of California, Los Angeles.
J Am Coll Dent. 1991 Summer;58(2):4-9.
The formation of the European Economic Community is resulting in historic changes. By the end of 1992, the European Community is expected to be operating as a single market of more than 320 million consumers, the largest in the world. The fundamental assumption underlying the creation of the European Community is that the best method to increase the general prosperity is a free market. The free market included services as well as goods and required the elimination of restrictions on the movement of people, goods and services among the 12 nations. In dentistry, this has already meant the elimination of licensure restriction for dentists in good standing who are citizens of the EEC and trained in approved educational programs within the EEC, but commercial barriers still remain to be eliminated by the end of 1992. The events occurring in Europe indicate that the outcome of the controversy regarding movement of dentists among states in the United States will be determined by larger societal considerations outside of the profession. The free market principle which underlies the changes in Europe is the fundamental economic philosophy in the United States. To the extent that limitation on the movement of health professionals is seen to contribute to higher costs for health care services in the United States, there may be increased efforts to license by credentials. Similarly, factors such as the need of families for greater freedom of movement between states and court challenges based on constitutionally protected rights may determine the outcome of licensure of dentists rather than issues which are of concern within the professional dental community.
欧洲经济共同体的形成正在带来历史性变革。到1992年底,欧洲共同体预计将作为一个拥有超过3.2亿消费者的单一市场运作,这将是世界上最大的市场。创建欧洲共同体的基本假设是,增加总体繁荣的最佳方法是自由市场。自由市场包括服务以及商品,并且要求消除12个国家之间人员、商品和服务流动的限制。在牙科领域,这已经意味着取消对信誉良好、身为欧洲经济共同体公民且在欧洲经济共同体内经批准的教育项目中受过培训的牙医的执照限制,但商业壁垒到1992年底仍有待消除。欧洲正在发生的这些事件表明,美国国内关于各州之间牙医流动争议的结果将由该行业之外更大的社会因素决定。作为欧洲变革基础的自由市场原则是美国的基本经济理念。如果限制卫生专业人员的流动被视为导致美国医疗服务成本上升,那么可能会加大基于资质颁发执照的力度。同样,诸如家庭对各州之间更大流动自由的需求以及基于宪法保护权利的法庭质疑等因素,可能会决定牙医执照颁发的结果,而不是专业牙科界所关注的问题。