Elnour A A, Harrison J
Research Centre for Injury Studies, Flinders University, Adelaide, SA, Australia.
Inj Prev. 2008 Feb;14(1):39-45. doi: 10.1136/ip.2007.016246.
To (a) quantify the lethality of suicide methods used in Australia in the period 1 July 1993 to 30 June 2003, (b) examine method-specific case fatality by age and sex, and (c) identify changes in case fatality during the study period.
Two sources of data on episodes of self-harm in Australia were used, mortality and hospital separation data. Double counting of cases recorded in both sources was controlled by omitting fatal hospital cases from estimates of episodes of self-harm.
Overall case fatality was 12%. For each suicide method, case fatality was higher in males and older age groups. Firearms were the most lethal suicide means (90%) followed by hanging (83%). Rates of suicide involving firearms declined over time, and those involving hanging rose. Case fatality for firearm cases changed little over time, but declined for self-harm by hanging/suffocation, poisoning, sharp objects, and crashing a motor vehicle.
This study (Australia) and two others (USA) show differences in method-specific lethality by gender and age. This study adds the finding of changes in lethality over time. Understanding of suicidality in populations, on which prevention efforts depend, requires explanation of these findings.
(a) 量化1993年7月1日至2003年6月30日期间澳大利亚使用的自杀方式的致死率;(b) 按年龄和性别检查特定方式的病死率;(c) 确定研究期间病死率的变化。
使用了澳大利亚自残事件的两个数据源,即死亡率和医院出院数据。通过在自残事件估计中排除致命的医院病例,控制了两个数据源中记录的病例的重复计数。
总体病死率为12%。对于每种自杀方式,男性和年龄较大的年龄组的病死率较高。枪支是最致命的自杀手段(90%),其次是上吊(83%)。涉及枪支的自杀率随时间下降,而上吊的自杀率上升。枪支案件的病死率随时间变化不大,但上吊/窒息、中毒、锐器和机动车碰撞导致的自残病死率下降。
本研究(澳大利亚)和其他两项研究(美国)显示了按性别和年龄划分的特定方式致死率的差异。本研究还发现了致死率随时间的变化。对人群自杀行为的理解是预防工作的基础,需要对这些发现作出解释。