Hocking Julia, Price Cathy J
Wellcome Trust Centre for Neuroimaging, University College London, London, WC1N 3BG UK.
Cereb Cortex. 2008 Oct;18(10):2439-49. doi: 10.1093/cercor/bhn007. Epub 2008 Feb 14.
In this study we investigate previous claims that a region in the left posterior superior temporal sulcus (pSTS) is more activated by audiovisual than unimodal processing. First, we compare audiovisual to visual-visual and auditory-auditory conceptual matching using auditory or visual object names that are paired with pictures of objects or their environmental sounds. Second, we compare congruent and incongruent audiovisual trials when presentation is simultaneous or sequential. Third, we compare audiovisual stimuli that are either verbal (auditory and visual words) or nonverbal (pictures of objects and their associated sounds). The results demonstrate that, when task, attention, and stimuli are controlled, pSTS activation for audiovisual conceptual matching is 1) identical to that observed for intramodal conceptual matching, 2) greater for incongruent than congruent trials when auditory and visual stimuli are simultaneously presented, and 3) identical for verbal and nonverbal stimuli. These results are not consistent with previous claims that pSTS activation reflects the active formation of an integrated audiovisual representation. After a discussion of the stimulus and task factors that modulate activation, we conclude that, when stimulus input, task, and attention are controlled, pSTS is part of a distributed set of regions involved in conceptual matching, irrespective of whether the stimuli are audiovisual, auditory-auditory or visual-visual.
在本研究中,我们调查了先前的说法,即左后颞上沟(pSTS)中的一个区域在视听处理时比单峰处理时更活跃。首先,我们使用与物体图片或其环境声音配对的听觉或视觉物体名称,将视听概念匹配与视觉-视觉和听觉-听觉概念匹配进行比较。其次,我们比较了呈现同时或相继时的一致和不一致视听试验。第三,我们比较了言语(听觉和视觉单词)或非言语(物体图片及其相关声音)的视听刺激。结果表明,当任务、注意力和刺激得到控制时,pSTS对视听概念匹配的激活:1)与模态内概念匹配时观察到的激活相同;2)当听觉和视觉刺激同时呈现时,不一致试验的激活大于一致试验;3)言语和非言语刺激的激活相同。这些结果与先前关于pSTS激活反映整合视听表征的主动形成的说法不一致。在讨论了调节激活的刺激和任务因素后,我们得出结论,当刺激输入、任务和注意力得到控制时,pSTS是参与概念匹配的一组分布式区域的一部分,无论刺激是视听、听觉-听觉还是视觉-视觉。