Azarpazhooh Amir, Main Patricia A
Community Dental Health Services Research Unit, Faculty of Dentistry, University of Toronto, 124 Edward Street, Toronto, ON M5G 1G6.
J Can Dent Assoc. 2008 Feb;74(1):73-9.
To develop a scientifically current and evidence-based protocol for the use of fluoride varnish for the prevention of dental caries among high-risk children and adolescents.
Previous systematic reviews on this topic were used as the basis for the current review. Ovid, MEDLINE, CINAHL and several other relevant bibliographic databases were searched for English-language articles, with human subjects, published from 2000 to 2007.
A total of 105 articles were identified by the literature search; relevance was determined by examining the title, abstract and body of the article. Seven original research studies met the inclusion criteria. These articles were read and scored independently by 2 reviewers, and evidence was extracted for systematic review.
The following recommendations were developed on the basis of the evidence: 1. For high-risk populations (e.g., people with low socioeconomic status, new immigrants and refugees, First Nations and Inuit children and adolescents), fluoride varnish should be applied twice a year, unless the individual has no risk of caries, as indicated by past and current caries history. This schedule of application would permit sealants to be checked biannually to ensure retention. 2. Single-dose packages of fluoride varnish should be used for children; the varnish in such packages should be stirred vigorously before application, to ensure that any precipitated fluoride is redissolved. 3. There is good evidence of the complementary efficacy of preventive strategies such as sealants and varnish, as well as toothbrushing and nutritional counselling; oral healthcare programs should therefore include as many complementary strategies as possible.
制定一项基于科学现状和证据的方案,用于高危儿童和青少年使用氟化物涂膜预防龋齿。
以往关于该主题的系统评价作为本次评价的基础。检索了Ovid、MEDLINE、CINAHL和其他几个相关书目数据库,查找2000年至2007年发表的涉及人类受试者的英文文章。
通过文献检索共识别出105篇文章;通过检查文章的标题、摘要和正文来确定相关性。七项原始研究符合纳入标准。这七篇文章由两名审阅者独立阅读并评分,并提取证据进行系统评价。
基于证据提出以下建议:1. 对于高危人群(如社会经济地位较低者、新移民和难民、原住民和因纽特儿童及青少年),应每年应用两次氟化物涂膜,除非根据过去和当前的龋齿病史表明个体无龋齿风险。这种应用时间表将允许每半年检查一次窝沟封闭剂以确保其留存情况。2. 儿童应使用单剂量包装的氟化物涂膜;此类包装中的涂膜在应用前应充分搅拌,以确保任何沉淀的氟重新溶解。3. 有充分证据表明窝沟封闭剂和涂膜等预防策略以及刷牙和营养咨询具有互补功效;因此口腔保健项目应尽可能纳入多种互补策略。