Cavallari Jennifer M, Fang Shona C, Eisen Ellen A, Schwartz Joel, Hauser Russ, Herrick Robert F, Christiani David C
Department of Environmental Health, Harvard School of Public Health, Boston, Massachusetts, USA.
Inhal Toxicol. 2008 Feb;20(4):415-22. doi: 10.1080/08958370801903800.
Although research suggests that particles influence cardiac autonomic response as evidenced by decreases in heart rate variability (HRV), the time course of the response remains unclear. Using a crossover panel study, we monitored 36 male boilermaker welders, occupationally exposed to metal-rich particulate matter (PM) to investigate the temporal trend of hourly HRV subsequent to PM exposure. Ambulatory electrocardiograms were collected over work (exposure) and non-work (control) periods and the mean of the standard deviations of all normal-to-normal intervals for all 5-min segments (SDNN(i)) was calculated hourly for up to 14-hrs post-work. The exposure-response relationship was examined with linear mixed effects regression models to account for participants monitored over multiple occasions. Models were adjusted for non-work HRV to control for diurnal fluctuations and individual predictors of HRV. The mean (SD) work PM(2. 5) concentration was 1.12 (0.76) mg/m(3). Hourly SDNN(i) was consistently lower post-work as compared to the same time period on a non-work day. HRV was inversely associated with work PM(2. 5) exposures in each of the 14-hrs post-work. The hourly associations suggested an early and later phase response, with the largest regression coefficients observed 2-3 hrs (beta = -6.86 (95% CI: -11.91, -1.81) msec/1 mg/m(3) at 3-hrs), and then 9-13 hrs (beta = -8.60 (95% CI: -17.45, 0.24) msec/1 mg/m(3) at 11-hrs), after adjusting for non-work HRV, smoking status, and age. This investigation demonstrates declines in HRV for up to 14 hours following PM exposure and a multiphase cardiovascular autonomic response with immediate (2 hrs) and delayed (9-13 hrs) responses.
尽管研究表明颗粒物会影响心脏自主神经反应,心率变异性(HRV)降低即为证据,但该反应的时间进程仍不明确。我们采用交叉面板研究,对36名职业性接触富含金属颗粒物(PM)的男性锅炉工焊工进行监测,以调查PM暴露后每小时HRV的时间趋势。在工作(暴露)和非工作(对照)期间收集动态心电图,并在工作后长达14小时内每小时计算所有5分钟时段正常到正常间隔的标准差均值(SDNN(i))。使用线性混合效应回归模型检查暴露-反应关系,以考虑在多个场合监测的参与者。模型针对非工作HRV进行了调整,以控制昼夜波动和HRV的个体预测因素。工作时PM(2.5)的平均(标准差)浓度为1.12(0.76)mg/m³。与非工作日的同一时间段相比,工作后每小时的SDNN(i)持续较低。在工作后14小时内的每一小时,HRV都与工作时PM(2.5)暴露呈负相关。每小时的关联表明存在早期和后期反应阶段,在调整非工作HRV、吸烟状况和年龄后,最大回归系数出现在2 - 3小时(3小时时β = -6.86(95%置信区间:-11.91,-1.81)msec/1 mg/m³),然后是9 - 13小时(11小时时β = -8.60(95%置信区间:-17.45,0.24)msec/1 mg/m³)。这项调查表明,PM暴露后长达14小时HRV会下降,并且存在多阶段心血管自主神经反应,包括即时(2小时)和延迟(9 - 13小时)反应。