Páez Borda A, Redondo González E, Ríos González E, Linares Quevedo A, Sáenz Medina J, Castillón Vela I
Servicio de Urología, Hospital de Fuenlabrada, Madrid.
Actas Urol Esp. 2007 Nov-Dec;31(10):1166-71. doi: 10.1016/s0210-4806(07)73780-4.
[corrected] To indirectly address the adequacy of referrals from general practitioners (GP) to specialized care taking into account a previously agreed protocol on ten urological topics.
MATERIALS & METHODS: The study analyzed all referrals to the Urology department originated in 10 primary care centres (135 GPs involved) throughout a 19-month period. Adequacy of 2841 referrals was checked. The urologist judged the referral as compliant (adequate) or not compliant (inadequate) with the terms of the protocol. Compliance per primary care centres was compared. Also referral adequacy corrected per centre and clinical topic was compared. The relationship between "absolute number of referrals" and "adequate referrals" was tested using a linear regression model.
57.2% of the referrals were inadequate. Overall, no significant differences were detected between primary care centres. Nevertheless significant differences between centres were evident in terms of referrals due to renal colic and female urinary incontinence. 70% (94/135) of the GPs complied with the protocol in, at least, 50% of the cases. A strong association between "absolute number of referrals" and "adequate referrals" was evident (r2=0.86).
Overall compliance with the protocol was modest. While no significant differences between centres were detected in terms of adequacy of referrals certain conditions have to be locally revisited; most of the topics (particularly microhematuria) have to be revisited in every center.
[已修正] 考虑到先前商定的关于十个泌尿外科主题的协议,间接评估全科医生(GP)向专科护理机构转诊的充分性。
本研究分析了在19个月期间源自10个初级保健中心(涉及135名全科医生)的所有泌尿外科转诊病例。检查了2841例转诊的充分性。泌尿科医生根据协议条款判断转诊是否合规(充分)或不合规(不充分)。比较了每个初级保健中心的合规情况。还比较了每个中心和临床主题校正后的转诊充分性。使用线性回归模型测试了“转诊绝对数量”与“充分转诊数量”之间的关系。
57.2%的转诊不充分。总体而言,初级保健中心之间未发现显著差异。然而,在因肾绞痛和女性尿失禁导致的转诊方面,各中心之间存在明显差异。70%(94/135)的全科医生在至少50%的病例中符合协议。“转诊绝对数量”与“充分转诊数量”之间存在明显的强关联(r2=0.86)。
总体而言,对协议的遵守程度一般。虽然在转诊充分性方面各中心之间未发现显著差异,但某些情况必须在当地重新审视;大多数主题(特别是微血尿)必须在每个中心重新审视。