Currie P, Saltissi S
Department of Cardiology, Royal Liverpool Hospital, U.K.
Eur Heart J. 1991 Jul;12(7):807-12. doi: 10.1093/eurheartj/12.7.807.
Current available calcium antagonists, although useful in angina pectoris, are often poorly tolerated. We therefore compared isradipine, a new calcium antagonist, with nifedipine in 18 patients with angina. Patients sequentially received incremental doses of either isradipine (IS) 2.5-7.5 mg three times daily or nifedipine (NF) 10-30 mg three times daily for 6 weeks each, in a randomized double-blind crossover study. Both agents produced similar (P = 0.43) increases in maximum exercise duration (IS + 30%; NF + 34%) and an equivalent (P = 0.38) increase in time to onset of angina on exercise (IS + 53%; NF + 62%). Both IS and NF significantly reduced exercise-induced ST depression (-40% and -45%) to a similar degree (P = 0.48). NF significantly (P = 0.019) reduced angina attacks (-3.0 attacks.week-1; 26%) compared to IS (-0.4; 4%) whilst a similar but non-significant trend in favour of NF was also apparent in the consumption of sublingual glyceryl trinitrate (-0.1 tablets.week-1; 2% vs +1.3.week-1; 23%; P = 0.28). However, significantly (P less than 0.03) more patients experienced adverse events whilst taking NF than with IS (36 events in 16/18 (89%) v 18 in 9/18 (50%). Thus, IS and NF increased exercise tolerance and reduced exercise angina and ST depression equally well although NF use was associated with fewer anginal episodes and IS with fewer side effects.
目前可用的钙拮抗剂尽管对心绞痛有效,但耐受性往往较差。因此,我们在18例心绞痛患者中比较了新型钙拮抗剂伊拉地平与硝苯地平的疗效。在一项随机双盲交叉研究中,患者依次接受递增剂量的伊拉地平(IS)2.5 - 7.5毫克,每日3次或硝苯地平(NF)10 - 30毫克,每日3次,各治疗6周。两种药物使最大运动持续时间增加程度相似(P = 0.43)(IS增加30%;NF增加34%),运动时心绞痛发作时间增加程度相当(P = 0.38)(IS增加53%;NF增加62%)。IS和NF均能使运动诱发的ST段压低显著降低(分别降低40%和45%),程度相似(P = 0.48)。与IS相比,NF能显著(P = 0.019)减少心绞痛发作次数(从每周3.0次减少至26%),而IS为(从每周0.4次减少至4%),同时在舌下含服硝酸甘油的用量方面,也有类似但不显著的有利于NF的趋势(从每周1.3片减少至23%,而IS从每周0.1片减少至2%;P = 0.28)。然而,服用NF时出现不良事件的患者显著多于服用IS的患者(16/18例(89%)出现36次不良事件,而9/18例(50%)出现18次)(P<0.03)。因此,IS和NF在提高运动耐力、减轻运动性心绞痛和ST段压低方面效果相当,尽管使用NF时心绞痛发作次数较少,而使用IS时副作用较少。