Nyiendo J
Western States Chiropractic College, Portland, OR 97230.
J Manipulative Physiol Ther. 1991 Jun;14(5):287-97.
Claimants in Oregon with disabling low back injuries attending chiropractors were found to have more treatments over a longer duration and at greater cost than claimants attending medical physicians with similar clinical presentations. These findings are attributed to: a) a higher proportion of chiropractic claimants than medical physician claimants with low back risk factors which may have adversely affected the course of recovery (chronic or recurrent low back conditions, obesity, extremity symptomatology, frequency of exacerbations); b) differences in age and gender of DC and MD claimants; c) the greater physician-patient contact hours characteristic of chiropractic practice; d) differences in therapeutic modalities employed; and e) the physician reimbursement permitted under Oregon workers' compensation law. The findings of this study emphasize the need for prospective studies of treatment outcome.
在俄勒冈州,因下背部损伤而就诊于脊椎按摩师的索赔者,与临床表现相似但就诊于内科医生的索赔者相比,接受治疗的时间更长、次数更多,费用也更高。这些发现归因于:a)与内科医生索赔者相比,脊椎按摩师索赔者中存在下背部风险因素的比例更高,这可能对康复过程产生了不利影响(慢性或复发性下背部疾病、肥胖、肢体症状、病情加重频率);b)脊椎按摩师和内科医生索赔者在年龄和性别上的差异;c)脊椎按摩疗法中医生与患者接触时间更长的特点;d)所采用治疗方式的差异;e)俄勒冈州工伤赔偿法允许的医生报销额度。本研究结果强调了对治疗结果进行前瞻性研究的必要性。