Burtin P, Bouché O, Giovannini M, Pelletier M, Conroy T, Ruget O, Arsène D, Milan C, Bedenne L
Gastroenterology, University Hospital, rue Larrey, 49033 Angers cedex 01, France.
Gastroenterol Clin Biol. 2008 Mar;32(3):213-20. doi: 10.1016/j.gcb.2007.12.026. Epub 2008 Mar 26.
No multivariate study has assessed the independent prognostic role of endoscopic ultrasonography (EUS) in esophageal cancer, even when considering computed tomography (CT).
To evaluate the prognostic value of EUS in esophageal cancer before exclusive or preoperative radiochemotherapy.
From 1993 to 1999, the FFCD 9102 study enrolled 444 patients who had cancer of the thoracic esophagus, stages T3-4, N0-1 and M0 on CT. The patients received two sessions of chemotherapy in addition to radiotherapy. The 259 patients with objective response and no contraindications for further treatment were randomized to undergo surgery or to continue with radiochemotherapy. EUS was performed in 174 patients enrolled in the trial (mean age: 59 years). Tumor characteristics and lymph node status were prospectively recorded. A Cox statistical model was used to identify any predictive prognostic factors among the clinical, EUS and CT data.
In the multivariate analysis, three factors were associated with a poor prognosis: inability to ingest solid food (OR: 1.98; P=0.0008); more than three neoplastic subdiaphragmatic lymph nodes (LN) on EUS (OR: 2.41; P<0.0045) and age>65 (OR: 1.53; P<0.056). Their prognostic value persisted after adjustment for type of treatment given. Two- and five- year survival rates were 21.5 and 10.5%, respectively, in the presence of three neoplastic subdiaphragmatic LN, and 43 and 30%, respectively, in all other cases.
Degree of dysphagia, age and presence of neoplastic subdiaphragmatic LN on EUS were independently predictive of the prognosis for locally advanced esophageal cancer. EUS results should be taken into account in future trials.
即便考虑到计算机断层扫描(CT),也尚无多变量研究评估内镜超声检查(EUS)在食管癌中的独立预后作用。
评估EUS在食管癌进行单纯或术前放化疗前的预后价值。
1993年至1999年,FFCD 9102研究纳入了444例胸段食管癌患者,这些患者在CT上表现为T3 - 4期、N0 - 1期和M0期。患者除接受放疗外还接受了两个疗程的化疗。259例有客观反应且无进一步治疗禁忌证的患者被随机分为接受手术或继续进行放化疗。174例纳入该试验的患者(平均年龄:59岁)接受了EUS检查。前瞻性记录肿瘤特征和淋巴结状态。使用Cox统计模型在临床、EUS和CT数据中识别任何预测预后因素。
在多变量分析中,三个因素与预后不良相关:无法摄入固体食物(比值比:1.98;P = 0.0008);EUS显示膈下肿瘤性淋巴结(LN)超过三个(比值比:2.41;P < 0.0045)以及年龄>65岁(比值比:1.53;P < 0.056)。在调整所给予的治疗类型后,它们的预后价值依然存在。在存在三个膈下肿瘤性LN的情况下,两年和五年生存率分别为21.5%和10.5%,在所有其他情况下分别为43%和30%。
吞咽困难程度、年龄以及EUS显示的膈下肿瘤性LN是局部晚期食管癌预后的独立预测因素。未来试验应考虑EUS结果。