Ramacciato Giovanni, Nigri Giuseppe, Di Santo Vincenzo, Piccoli Michaela, Pansadoro Vito, Buniva Paolo, Bellagamba Riccardo, Cescon Matteo, Ercolani Giorgio, Cucchetti Alessandro, Lauro Augusto, Del Gaudio Massimo, Ravaioli Matteo, Valabrega Stefano, D'Angelo Francesco, Aurello Paolo, Stigliano Antonio, Toscano Vincenzo, Melotti Gianluigi
Chirurgia Generale D, Azienda Ospedaliera Sant'Andrea, II Facoltà di Medicina e Chirurgia, Università degli Studi La Sapienza, Roma.
Chir Ital. 2008 Jan-Feb;60(1):15-22.
Laparoscopic adrenalectomy is now regarded as the procedure of choice for most adrenal glands presenting surgical pathology. The primary adrenal-specific contraindication to laparoscopic adrenalectomy today is the presence of a large adrenal mass with evidence of local infiltration or venous invasion. We used our multicentre experience to compare the transperitoneal (TLA) and retroperitoneal (RLA) minimally invasive approaches. In our study we found statistically significant differences between RLA and TLA in terms of duration of surgery (148 minuti vs. 112; p < 0.005), intra-operative blood loss (439 cc vs 333 p < 0.005; p < 0.005) and time of first oral intake (1.2 +/- 0.5 days vs 1.8 +/- 1.08 days; p < 0.005). The RLA approach is preferable in cases of previous abdominal surgery, but its learning curve is extremely steep. TLA access needs a less demanding learning curve and tends to be faster than RLA, where the working area is penalised by limited manoeuvring space. There is no clear preference between TLA and RLA in the literature. However, the experience of the surgeon still remains the most important variable when choosing between the two approaches.
如今,腹腔镜肾上腺切除术被视为大多数存在手术病理的肾上腺疾病的首选手术方式。目前腹腔镜肾上腺切除术主要的肾上腺特异性禁忌证是存在巨大肾上腺肿块且有局部浸润或静脉侵犯的证据。我们利用多中心经验比较了经腹(TLA)和腹膜后(RLA)微创方法。在我们的研究中,我们发现RLA和TLA在手术时间(148分钟对112分钟;p<0.005)、术中失血量(439毫升对333毫升;p<0.005)以及首次经口进食时间(1.2±0.5天对1.8±1.08天;p<0.005)方面存在统计学显著差异。RLA方法在既往有腹部手术史的病例中更可取,但其学习曲线极为陡峭。TLA入路所需的学习曲线要求较低,且往往比RLA更快,在RLA中操作空间有限会影响工作区域。文献中对于TLA和RLA没有明确的偏好。然而,在选择这两种方法时,外科医生的经验仍然是最重要的变量。