Franklin Diane E, Taylor Catherine L, Hennessey Neville W, Beilby Janet M
School of Psychology, Curtin University of Technology, GPO Box U1987, Perth, Western Australia 6845.
Int J Lang Commun Disord. 2008 May-Jun;43(3):283-99. doi: 10.1080/13682820701449893.
Response-contingent time-out has been shown to be an effective technique for enhancing fluency in people who stutter. However, the factors that determine individual responsiveness to time-out are not well understood.
The study investigated the effectiveness of using response-contingent time-out to reduce stuttering frequency in adults who stutter. In addition, it investigated the predictive value of participants' stutter severity, age, previous treatment history, and type of stutter on the responsiveness to time-out conditioning.
METHODS & PROCEDURES: Sixty people who stutter participated in the study. Half were exposed to time-out following each moment of stuttering over a 40-min period, the remaining participants acted as controls.
OUTCOMES & RESULTS: Results showed that individuals who stutter are highly responsive to time-out, and that the participants with a more severe stutter responded better than those with a mild stutter. To a lesser degree, previous treatment and speech rate also influenced treatment success. Age and type of stutter did not, although the proportion of repetition types of stutters increased over the experiment conditions, with prolongations and blocks decreasing, for the treatment group.
This simple operant conditioning treatment method is effective in reducing stuttering. Individuals respond to time-out regardless of their age, type of stutter, stuttering severity or treatment history, thus it is a treatment methodology potentially suitable for all clients. This study investigated initial responsiveness to time-out; therefore, further research is necessary to determine the durability of fluency over time.
基于反应的暂停已被证明是一种提高口吃者流畅性的有效技术。然而,决定个体对暂停反应性的因素尚未得到充分理解。
本研究调查了使用基于反应的暂停来降低成年口吃者口吃频率的有效性。此外,还研究了参与者的口吃严重程度、年龄、既往治疗史和口吃类型对暂停条件反应性的预测价值。
60名口吃者参与了该研究。其中一半在40分钟内每口吃一次就接受暂停处理,其余参与者作为对照组。
结果表明,口吃者对暂停反应强烈,口吃较严重的参与者比轻度口吃者反应更好。既往治疗和语速在较小程度上也影响治疗效果。年龄和口吃类型则没有影响,不过在实验条件下,治疗组中重复型口吃的比例增加,拖音和阻塞型口吃减少。
这种简单的操作性条件治疗方法在减少口吃方面是有效的。个体无论年龄、口吃类型、口吃严重程度或治疗史如何,都对暂停有反应,因此它是一种可能适用于所有患者的治疗方法。本研究调查了对暂停的初始反应性;因此,有必要进一步研究以确定流畅性随时间的持久性。