Shahidzadeh-Mahani Ali, Omidvari Sepideh, Baradaran Hamid-Reza, Azin Seyyed-Ali
Department of Community Medicine, Institute for Health Science Research, Tehran, Iran.
Int J Qual Health Care. 2008 Aug;20(4):284-90. doi: 10.1093/intqhc/mzn016. Epub 2008 May 6.
Despite good contraceptive coverage rates, recent studies in Iran have shown an alarmingly high incidence of unplanned pregnancy.
To determine factors affecting quality of family planning services, a cross-sectional study was performed from June to August 2006 on women visiting urban Primary Health Care clinics in a provincial capital in western Iran. The primary focus of the study was on provider-client interaction.
We used a slightly edited version of a UNICEF checklist and a convenient sampling method to assess quality of care in 396 visits to the family planning sections at 25 delivery points.
Poor performance was observed notably in Counselling and Choice of method sections. In logistic regression analysis, the following factors were found to be associated with higher quality of care: provider experience [OR (odds ratio)=1.9, CI(0.95) (confidence interval)=1.2-3.0], low provider education (OR=6.7, CI(0.95)=4.0-10.8), smaller workload at the clinic (OR=3.7, CI(0.95)=2.0-6.7), and 'new client' status (OR=4.2, CI(0.95)=2.6-6.7).
This study identified the issues of counselling and information exchange as the quality domains in serious need of improvement; these areas are expected to be the focus of future training programmes for care providers. Also, priority should be given to devising effective supervision mechanisms and on-the-job training of senior nursing and midwifery graduates to make them more competent in delivering basic family planning services.
尽管避孕普及率良好,但伊朗最近的研究显示意外怀孕发生率高得惊人。
为确定影响计划生育服务质量的因素,2006年6月至8月对访问伊朗西部一个省会城市初级卫生保健诊所的妇女进行了一项横断面研究。该研究的主要重点是提供者与服务对象的互动。
我们使用了联合国儿童基金会检查表的一个略作编辑的版本,并采用便利抽样方法,对25个分娩点的计划生育科室的396次就诊的护理质量进行评估。
在咨询和方法选择方面表现不佳。在逻辑回归分析中,发现以下因素与更高的护理质量相关:提供者经验[比值比(OR)=1.9,95%置信区间(CI)=1.2 - 3.0]、提供者教育程度低(OR = 6.7,CI(0.95)= 4.0 - 10.8)、诊所工作量小(OR = 3.7,CI(0.95)= 2.0 - 6.7)以及“新服务对象”身份(OR = 4.2,CI(0.95)= 2.6 - 6.7)。
本研究确定咨询和信息交流问题是急需改进的质量领域;这些领域预计将成为未来护理提供者培训计划的重点。此外,应优先制定有效的监督机制,并对高级护理和助产专业毕业生进行在职培训,以使他们更有能力提供基本的计划生育服务。