Wang Bin, Yu Gang, Huang Jun, Hu Hongying
Department of Environmental Science and Engineering, POPs Research Centre, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, China.
Ecotoxicology. 2008 Nov;17(8):716-24. doi: 10.1007/s10646-008-0220-2. Epub 2008 May 8.
Eighteen organochlorine pesticides (OCPs) were studied to develop species sensitivity distributions (SSDs) and calculate hazardous concentration thresholds for 5% of species (HC5), using both parametric (log-normal and log-logistic) and nonparametric bootstrap methods. In order to avoid picking repetitive values in each resample when performing bootstrap, and to determine the influence of fluctuation of toxicity data of single species on the SSDs and HC5, a modified bootstrap method was introduced, which can generate unrepetitive sampling data other than original elements in datasets. This method can enlarge a dataset without any assumption of a special distribution. Combined with parametric methods, modified bootstrap was also used to develop SSDs and determine HC5. The HC5 estimated by five approaches coincide well with each other with good positive correlation. Even if there is intra-species variation in a certain range of toxicity data; SSDs and HC5 are not very sensitive to the local fluctuation of toxicity of single species. The studied OCPs were classified according to their estimated HC5. A lower HC5 indicates higher ecological toxicity potentials. Endrin, DDTs and Endosulfan are OCPs with very high ecological toxicity potential. alpha-HCH has the lowest ecological toxicity potential in the studied OCPs. For OCPs with high ecological potential, more attention should be paid to their ecological risk.
研究了18种有机氯农药(OCPs),采用参数法(对数正态和对数逻辑斯蒂)和非参数自助法来建立物种敏感度分布(SSD)并计算5%物种的危险浓度阈值(HC5)。为了在进行自助抽样时避免在每个重采样中选取重复值,并确定单一物种毒性数据波动对SSD和HC5的影响,引入了一种改进的自助法,该方法可以生成除数据集中原始元素之外的无重复抽样数据。此方法无需对特殊分布做任何假设就能扩大数据集。结合参数法,改进的自助法也用于建立SSD并确定HC5。通过五种方法估算的HC5相互吻合良好,呈显著正相关。即使在一定毒性数据范围内存在种内变异,SSD和HC5对单一物种毒性的局部波动也不太敏感。根据估算的HC5对所研究的OCPs进行分类。较低的HC5表明生态毒性潜力较高。异狄氏剂、滴滴涕和硫丹是具有极高生态毒性潜力的OCPs。在所研究的OCPs中,α-六氯环己烷的生态毒性潜力最低。对于具有高生态潜力的OCPs,应更加关注其生态风险。