Worley Matthew, Gallop Robert, Gibbons Mary Beth Connolly, Ring-Kurtz Sarah, Present Julie, Weiss Roger D, Crits-Christoph Paul
Department of Psychiatry, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA.
Am J Addict. 2008 May-Jun;17(3):209-17. doi: 10.1080/10550490802021994.
The objective of this study was to examine the level of additional treatment services obtained by patients enrolled in the NIDA Cocaine Collaborative Study, a multi-center efficacy trial of four treatments for cocaine dependence, and to determine whether these services impact treatment outcome. Cocaine-dependent patients (N = 487) were recruited at five sites and randomly assigned to six months of one of four psychosocial treatments. Assessments were made at baseline, monthly during treatment, and at follow-ups at 9, 12, 15, and 18 months post-randomization. On average, patients received little or no additional treatment services during active treatment (first six months), but the rate of obtaining most services increased during the follow-up phase (month 7 to 18). In general, the treatment groups did not differ in the rates of obtaining non-protocol services. For all treatment groups, patients with greater psychiatric severity received more medical and psychiatric services during active treatment and follow-up. Use of treatment services was unrelated to drug use outcomes during active treatment. However, during the follow-up period, increased use of psychiatric medication, twelve-step attendance, and twelve-step participation was related to less drug use. The results suggest that during uncontrolled follow-up phases, additional non-protocol services may potentially confound the interpretation of treatment group comparisons in drug use outcomes.
本研究的目的是调查参与美国国立药物滥用研究所可卡因合作研究的患者所获得的额外治疗服务水平。该研究是一项针对可卡因依赖的四种治疗方法的多中心疗效试验,旨在确定这些服务是否会影响治疗结果。在五个地点招募了487名可卡因依赖患者,并将他们随机分配到四种心理社会治疗方法中的一种,接受为期六个月的治疗。在基线、治疗期间每月以及随机分组后9、12、15和18个月的随访时进行评估。平均而言,患者在积极治疗期间(前六个月)接受的额外治疗服务很少或没有,但在随访阶段(第7至18个月)获得大多数服务的比率有所增加。总体而言,治疗组在获得非方案服务的比率上没有差异。对于所有治疗组,精神疾病严重程度较高的患者在积极治疗和随访期间接受了更多的医疗和精神服务。在积极治疗期间,治疗服务的使用与药物使用结果无关。然而,在随访期间,精神科药物使用的增加、参加十二步治疗法以及参与十二步治疗法与较少的药物使用有关。结果表明,在无对照的随访阶段,额外的非方案服务可能会混淆对治疗组药物使用结果比较的解释。