Hueston William J, Quattlebaum Robert G, Benich Joseph J
Department of Family Medicine, Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, SC 29425, USA.
J Am Board Fam Med. 2008 May-Jun;21(3):184-90. doi: 10.3122/jabfm.2008.03.070215.
Pregnant teens in the United States are at high risk for not obtaining prenatal care and for having low-birth weight deliveries. This observation suggests that significant cost savings might be realized if teens were able to obtain prenatal care in a timely fashion.
To determine the optimal time for teens to start prenatal care, we conducted a cost-benefit analysis from the perspective of Medicaid, the predominant payer for pregnancy-related services for teens. Cost projections were based on current recommended prenatal care testing, the cost of vaginal and cesarean deliveries, and the estimated costs for care of the child in the first year of life. We then compared average cost per person and performed sensitivity analyses based on when prenatal care would have started.
Compared with no prenatal care, any prenatal care saves between $2,369 and $3,242 per person, depending on when care is initiated. All savings are related to reductions in the cost of caring for low-birth weight babies. We found no cost advantage to starting prenatal care earlier compared with later months.
If prenatal care does reduce the rate of low-birth weight babies, prenatal care is cost beneficial. If a program was developed to improve access for teens and applied to all pregnant teens not in care by 6 months' gestation, the program would have to average $95 or less per person to be cost beneficial if it reduced the number of low-birth weight deliveries by 50%.
美国的青少年孕妇面临未接受产前护理以及分娩低体重儿的高风险。这一现象表明,如果青少年能够及时获得产前护理,可能会实现显著的成本节约。
为了确定青少年开始产前护理的最佳时间,我们从医疗补助(为青少年提供与怀孕相关服务的主要支付方)的角度进行了成本效益分析。成本预测基于当前推荐的产前护理检查、阴道分娩和剖宫产的费用,以及孩子出生第一年的护理估计费用。然后,我们比较了人均成本,并根据产前护理开始的时间进行了敏感性分析。
与未接受产前护理相比,任何产前护理每人可节省2369美元至3242美元,具体取决于护理开始的时间。所有节省都与降低低体重儿护理成本有关。我们发现,与在孕晚期开始产前护理相比,在孕早期开始并没有成本优势。
如果产前护理确实能降低低体重儿的出生率,那么产前护理在成本方面是有益的。如果制定一个项目来改善青少年获得护理的机会,并将其应用于所有怀孕6个月仍未接受护理的青少年,那么如果该项目能将低体重儿分娩数量减少50%,其人均成本必须平均为95美元或更低才具有成本效益。