Hanson Christopher S, Schneider Dona, Hill Ann Marie
Edward J. Bloustein School of Planning and Public Policy Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey, 33 Livingston Avenue, New Brunswick, NJ 08901-1958, United States.
Health Policy. 2008 Dec;88(2-3):243-9. doi: 10.1016/j.healthpol.2008.03.007. Epub 2008 May 12.
Seed grant programs have been suggested as an innovative way to launch new initiatives. We evaluated one such program designed to stimulate cancer research in a state with little to moderate cancer research activity. Success was defined as the ability of seed grant recipients to develop proposals, obtain external funding and publish the results of cancer-related research.
Data were collected through the Internet from a variety of funding and publication databases, as well as through updated curriculum vitae and a mail survey of the seed grant recipients.
Fifteen (31%) experienced investigators and 33 (69%) new investigators credited their seed grants with helping them leverage 60 active research grants and 10 pending proposals with a variety of funders. Overall, seed grant recipients leveraged $10.10 for every dollar of seed grant funding they received. Anecdotal evidence showed that seed grants allowed grantees to establish themselves as legitimate cancer research investigators, develop and fund their laboratories, and focus or refocus their work. These results are from a single case study.
Seed grants for pilot projects inexpensively and efficiently built cancer research capacity in a state with historically low levels of national cancer research funding. As our findings are based on a single case study, we cannot state that this strategy would succeed for other states in similar circumstances.
种子基金项目被认为是启动新计划的一种创新方式。我们评估了一个旨在刺激癌症研究的此类项目,该项目针对的是一个癌症研究活动较少至中等的州。成功的定义为种子基金获得者制定提案、获得外部资金并发表癌症相关研究成果的能力。
通过互联网从各种资金和出版物数据库收集数据,以及通过更新的简历和对种子基金获得者的邮件调查收集数据。
15名(31%)经验丰富的研究人员和33名(69%)新研究人员认为他们的种子基金帮助他们利用这些资金从各类资助者那里获得了60项正在进行的研究资助和10项待决提案。总体而言,种子基金获得者每获得1美元的种子基金资助,就能撬动10.10美元的资金。轶事证据表明,种子基金使受资助者能够确立自己作为合法癌症研究人员的地位,建立并资助他们的实验室,并调整或重新调整他们的工作重点。这些结果来自一个单一案例研究。
针对试点项目的种子基金以低成本且高效的方式在一个国家癌症研究资金历史水平较低的州建立了癌症研究能力。由于我们的研究结果基于一个单一案例研究,我们不能断言这种策略在类似情况下对其他州也会成功。