Isaksson Ulf, Aström Sture, Graneheim Ulla Hällgren
Department of Nursing, Umeå University, Umeå, Sweden.
J Clin Nurs. 2008 Jun;17(12):1660-6. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2702.2007.02196.x.
This study illuminates how female caregivers in nursing home perceive violence.
Previous studies have focused on prevalence and types of violence and injuries in various settings and among various professionals. There are, however, few studies that examine how caregivers perceive violence.
Forty-one female caregivers at nursing homes were asked to reflect on a vignette containing a situation where a female caregiver is exposed to violence from a male resident. The reflections were analysed by qualitative content analysis.
The main finding indicates that perceiving an action as violent is in the eye of the beholder. Caregivers perceive violence to be challenging, intentional, excusable, ordinary and contextual relative to their own experience and attitudes.
As the perception of violence is subjective, there is a risk that violent incidents will be under-reported as well as over-reported. To avoid this, it is important to construct a well-defined operationalised definition of violence for research purposes. Our findings also indicate the need for individually structured and adjusted support for caregivers. To explore the complexity of violence, further research should focus on how caregivers and residents experience violence in a nursing home.
本研究阐明了养老院女性护理人员如何看待暴力行为。
以往的研究主要关注不同环境及各类专业人员中暴力行为、伤害的发生率和类型。然而,很少有研究探讨护理人员如何看待暴力行为。
研究要求41位养老院女性护理人员对一段描述女性护理人员遭受男性住客暴力行为的短文进行思考,并通过定性内容分析法对她们的思考内容进行分析。
主要研究结果表明,对暴力行为的认知因人而异。护理人员根据自身经历和态度,认为暴力行为具有挑战性、是故意的、情有可原的、常见的且与具体情境相关。
由于对暴力行为的认知是主观的,暴力事件可能存在报告不足或报告过度的风险。为避免这种情况,为研究目的构建明确的、可操作的暴力行为定义非常重要。我们的研究结果还表明,需要为护理人员提供个性化的、有针对性的支持。为探究暴力行为的复杂性,未来研究应聚焦于护理人员和住客在养老院中如何体验暴力行为。