Premadasa I G, Shehab Diaa, Al-Jarallah Khaled F, Thalib Lukman
Kuwait Institute for Medical Specialization, Kuwait.
Med Teach. 2008;30(3):e60-5. doi: 10.1080/01421590801915652.
Several investigations suggest inadequate emphasis of basic clinical procedures during internship training. Many trainees had reported lack of competence, while some expressed confidence to manage conditions although not sufficiently experienced.
This study aimed at ascertaining the perceptions of new medical graduates regarding the performance of core clinical skills during training and confidence of performing them later. It also aimed at determining any gender variability in the confidence in performing selected clinical skills in Obstetrics & Gynaecology.
Interns trained during 2005/06 responded anonymously to a questionnaire that listed 48 core clinical skills. The 124 subjects eligible for the study comprised graduates from Kuwait (64), other Gulf Cooperation Council countries (29), Ireland (27) and Egypt. They indicated whether they felt confident to perform the skills in future, and the number of times they had performed them during training. We received 91 completed questionnaires.
The majority felt confident in performing routine skills (basic ECG and X-ray interpretations, insertion of intravenous line, inserting urethral catheter and nasogastric feeding). Approximately two thirds had performed generic skills related to emergency resuscitation, with a half of them confident in performing them in the future. A third felt confident in performing artificial ventilation and endotracheal intubation. The confidence to perform common skills in Obstetrics & Gynaecology varied, with no significant gender variation. Approximately a fifth was confident in performing lumbar puncture, needle aspiration of joints, insertion of thoracic drainage, insertion of central venous catheter, venous cut-down and indirect laryngoscopy. A small proportion reported confidence in performing different clinical procedures although they had not undertaken them during training.
Substantial proportions of trainees lacked confidence in performing emergency resuscitative measures and some routine clinical skills. Training needs to be closely monitored and interns who are not competent identified early for taking remedial measures.
多项调查表明,实习培训期间对基本临床操作的重视不足。许多实习生报告称自己能力欠缺,而一些人虽经验不足,但表示有信心处理各种情况。
本研究旨在确定新毕业医学学生对培训期间核心临床技能表现的看法以及日后执行这些技能的信心。同时,研究还旨在确定在妇产科特定临床技能操作信心方面是否存在性别差异。
2005/06年期间接受培训的实习生对一份列出48项核心临床技能的问卷进行匿名回复。符合研究条件的124名受试者包括科威特(64人)、其他海湾合作委员会国家(29人)、爱尔兰(27人)和埃及的毕业生。他们表明自己是否有信心在未来执行这些技能,以及在培训期间执行这些技能的次数。我们共收到91份完整问卷。
大多数人对执行常规技能(基本心电图和X光解读、静脉输液管插入、尿道导管插入和鼻饲)有信心。约三分之二的人进行过与紧急复苏相关的一般技能操作,其中一半人有信心在未来执行这些操作。三分之一的人对进行人工通气和气管插管有信心。在妇产科执行常见技能的信心各不相同,且无显著性别差异。约五分之一的人对进行腰椎穿刺、关节穿刺抽吸、胸腔引流管插入、中心静脉导管插入、静脉切开术和间接喉镜检查有信心。一小部分人表示,尽管他们在培训期间未进行过不同的临床操作,但对执行这些操作有信心。
相当一部分实习生对执行紧急复苏措施和一些常规临床技能缺乏信心。培训需要密切监督,早期识别出能力不足的实习生并采取补救措施。