Dewulf Jo, Van Langenhove Herman, Muys Bart, Bruers Stijn, Bakshi Bhavik R, Grubb Geoffrey F, Paulus D M, Sciubba Enrico
Ghent University, Ghent, Belgium.
Environ Sci Technol. 2008 Apr 1;42(7):2221-32. doi: 10.1021/es071719a.
New technologies, either renewables-based or not, are confronted with both economic and technical constraints. Their development takes advantage of considering the basic laws of economics and thermodynamics. With respect to the latter, the exergy concept pops up. Although its fundamentals, that is, the Second Law of Thermodynamics, were already established in the 1800s, it is only in the last years that the exergy concept has gained a more widespread interest in process analysis, typically employed to identify inefficiencies. However, exergy analysis today is implemented far beyond technical analysis; it is also employed in environmental, (thermo)economic, and even sustainability analysis of industrial systems. Because natural ecosystems are also subjected to the basic laws of thermodynamics, it is another subject of exergy analysis. After an introduction on the concept itself, this review focuses on the potential and limitations of the exergy conceptin (1) ecosystem analysis, utilized to describe maximum storage and maximum dissipation of energy flows (2); industrial system analysis: from single process analysis to complete process chain analysis (3); (thermo)economic analysis, with extended exergy accounting; and (4) environmental impact assessment throughout the whole life cycle with quantification of the resource intake and emission effects. Apart from technical system analysis, it proves that exergy as a tool in environmental impact analysis may be the most mature field of application, particularly with respect to resource and efficiency accounting, one of the major challenges in the development of sustainable technology. Far less mature is the exergy analysis of natural ecosystems and the coupling with economic analysis, where a lively debate is presently going on about the actual merits of an exergy-based approach.
新技术,无论是否基于可再生能源,都面临着经济和技术方面的限制。它们的发展得益于对经济学和热力学基本定律的考量。关于后者,火用概念应运而生。尽管其基本原理,即热力学第二定律,在19世纪就已确立,但直到最近几年,火用概念才在过程分析中获得了更广泛的关注,通常用于识别低效率问题。然而,如今火用分析的应用已远远超出技术分析范畴;它还被用于工业系统的环境、(热)经济乃至可持续性分析。由于自然生态系统也遵循热力学基本定律,所以它也是火用分析的另一个对象。在对该概念本身进行介绍之后,本综述重点关注火用概念在以下方面的潜力和局限性:(1)生态系统分析,用于描述能量流的最大存储和最大耗散;(2)工业系统分析:从单过程分析到完整过程链分析;(3)(热)经济分析,采用扩展火用核算;以及(4)在整个生命周期内进行环境影响评估,量化资源摄入和排放效应。除了技术系统分析外,事实证明,火用作为环境影响分析的工具,可能是最成熟的应用领域,尤其是在资源和效率核算方面,这是可持续技术发展中的主要挑战之一。自然生态系统的火用分析以及与经济分析的耦合则远未成熟,目前关于基于火用方法的实际优点正在进行激烈辩论。