Kotani Jin, Kawabe Joji, Higashiyama Shigeaki, Kawamura Etsushi, Oe Ai, Hayashi Takehiro, Kurooka Hiroko, Tsumoto Chikako, Kusuki Makoto, Yamane Hideo, Shiomi Susumu
Department of Nuclear Medicine, Graduate School of Medicine, Osaka City University, 1-4-3 Asahimachi, Abeno-ku, Osaka, Japan.
Ann Nucl Med. 2008 May;22(4):297-300. doi: 10.1007/s12149-007-0116-x. Epub 2008 Jun 6.
Single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) using gallium (Ga) has been frequently used for diagnosing head and neck tumors in patients. Although the usefulness of Ga-SPECT is well known, the degree of the increase in diagnostic ability with Ga-SPECT for head and neck tumors has not been reported. We compared the ability of the planar images of Ga scintigraphy, SPECT images of Ga scintigraphy, and CT images to diagnose head and neck primary tumors and neck metastases.
The subjects of this study were 167 patients with malignant head/neck lesions. For Ga scintigraphy, Ga-67-citrate (74 MBq) was injected via a cubital vein. Planar and SPECT images were taken 72 h after the Ga-67-citrate injection. The rate of detection of the primary lesions was compared first between SPECT and planar images then between SPECT and CT images. The rate of detection for each stage of disease according to the TNM classification was also analyzed.
The rate of detection of primary lesions was 50% with planar imaging and 69% with SPECT. And similarly, regarding the rate of detection of lymph node metastases, there was a significant difference between planar imaging and SPECT. The rate of detection of primary lesions was 70% for both CT and SPECT. At T stage, the rates of detection of primary lesions with each imaging technique were 11% with planar imaging and 39% with SPECT, and 22% with CT for stage T1.
This study revealed the marked superiority of SPECT images over planar images in terms of the ability to detect primary tumors and tumor metastasis to cervical lymph nodes. Furthermore, the primary T1 tumor detection rate of SPECT images was higher than that of CT images. On the basis of these results, the concomitant use of SPECT is highly recommended when Ga scintigraphy is performed to check for malignant head/neck tumors.
利用镓(Ga)的单光子发射计算机断层扫描(SPECT)已被频繁用于诊断患者的头颈部肿瘤。尽管Ga-SPECT的实用性广为人知,但尚未有关于Ga-SPECT对头颈部肿瘤诊断能力提高程度的报道。我们比较了Ga闪烁显像的平面图像、Ga闪烁显像的SPECT图像以及CT图像诊断头颈部原发性肿瘤和颈部转移瘤的能力。
本研究的对象为167例患有头颈部恶性病变的患者。对于Ga闪烁显像,通过肘静脉注射74 MBq的枸橼酸镓-67。在注射枸橼酸镓-67后72小时拍摄平面图像和SPECT图像。首先比较SPECT图像与平面图像之间原发性病变的检出率,然后比较SPECT图像与CT图像之间的检出率。还分析了根据TNM分类的各疾病阶段的检出率。
平面成像对原发性病变的检出率为50%,SPECT为69%。同样,关于淋巴结转移的检出率,平面成像与SPECT之间存在显著差异。CT和SPECT对原发性病变的检出率均为70%。在T分期,对于T1期,每种成像技术对原发性病变的检出率分别为:平面成像11%,SPECT 39%,CT 22%。
本研究揭示了SPECT图像在检测原发性肿瘤和肿瘤转移至颈部淋巴结的能力方面明显优于平面图像。此外,SPECT图像对原发性T1肿瘤的检出率高于CT图像。基于这些结果,在进行Ga闪烁显像检查头颈部恶性肿瘤时,强烈建议同时使用SPECT。