Johnson Luke J, Cope Marcus R, Shahrokhi Shahram, Tamblyn Peter
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Flinders Medical Centre, Bedford Park, South Australia, Australia.
Injury. 2008 Jul;39(7):786-90. doi: 10.1016/j.injury.2007.12.019. Epub 2008 Jun 9.
The sliding hip screw is currently the most frequently used prosthesis used to fix trochanteric fractures of the hip. The 'tip-apex distance' (TAD) has been found to be predictive of hardware failure, with a larger TAD being associated with an increasing risk of 'cut-out'. Previous studies have either used 'hard-copy' radiographs and geometrical aids or a mixture of scanned hard-copy images and extra software to measure TAD. The current study describes a new method of tip-apex distance estimation using an entirely digital picture archiving and communication system (PACS).
Ten radiographs were measured for TAD by four surgeons of differing experience using the described measurement protocol, at two different time points (4 weeks apart). The results were then subjected to two-tailed t-tests to determine if they differed significantly.
No tests attained significance (i.e. no statistical difference existed between the observers' measurements and no difference existed over time from a single observer's results).
This study shows that TAD can be easily, accurately and, importantly, reproducibly measured using an entirely digitally based image capture and archiving system. The ease with which the measurements and calculations can be made will facilitate orthopaedic practitioners and trauma units in their auditing activities, and allows for quick TAD estimation in the 'X-ray meeting' environment.
滑动髋螺钉是目前用于固定髋部转子间骨折最常用的假体。已发现“尖顶距”(TAD)可预测内固定失败,TAD越大,“穿出”风险越高。以往研究要么使用“硬拷贝”X线片和几何辅助工具,要么结合扫描的硬拷贝图像和额外软件来测量TAD。本研究描述了一种使用完全数字化的图像存档与通信系统(PACS)估算尖顶距的新方法。
由四位经验不同的外科医生按照所述测量方案,在两个不同时间点(间隔4周)对十张X线片测量TAD。然后对结果进行双尾t检验,以确定它们是否存在显著差异。
所有检验均未达到显著性(即观察者测量结果之间无统计学差异,且单个观察者的结果在不同时间无差异)。
本研究表明,使用完全基于数字的图像采集和存档系统可以轻松、准确且重要的是可重复地测量TAD。测量和计算的简便性将有助于骨科医生和创伤科室开展审核工作,并能在“X线会诊”环境中快速估算TAD。