Kaissi Amer A, Begun James W
Department of Health Care Administration, Trinity University, San Antonio, Texas, USA.
J Healthc Manag. 2008 May-Jun;53(3):197-208; discussion 208-9.
Many common management practices in healthcare organizations, including the practice of strategic planning, have not been subject to widespread assessment through empirical research. If management practice is to be evidence-based, evaluations of such common practices need to be undertaken. The purpose of this research is to provide evidence on the extent of strategic planning practices and the association between hospital strategic planning processes and financial performance. In 2006, we surveyed a sample of 138 chief executive officers (CEOs) of hospitals in the state of Texas about strategic planning in their organizations and collected financial information on the hospitals for 2003. Among the sample hospitals, 87 percent reported having a strategic plan, and most reported that they followed a variety of common practices recommended for strategic planning-having a comprehensive plan, involving physicians, involving the board, and implementing the plan. About one-half of the hospitals assigned responsibility for the plan to the CEO. We tested the association between these planning characteristics in 2006 and two measures of financial performance for 2003. Three dimensions of the strategic planning process--having a strategic plan, assigning the CEO responsibility for the plan, and involving the board--are positively associated with earlier financial performance. Further longitudinal studies are needed to evaluate the cause-and-effect relationship between planning and performance.
医疗保健组织中的许多常见管理做法,包括战略规划实践,尚未通过实证研究进行广泛评估。如果管理实践要以证据为基础,就需要对这些常见做法进行评估。本研究的目的是提供有关战略规划实践程度以及医院战略规划过程与财务绩效之间关联的证据。2006年,我们对得克萨斯州138家医院的首席执行官就其组织中的战略规划进行了抽样调查,并收集了这些医院2003年的财务信息。在抽样医院中,87%的医院报告有战略计划,且大多数医院报告称他们遵循了战略规划推荐的各种常见做法——制定全面计划、让医生参与、让董事会参与以及实施该计划。约一半的医院将计划责任交给了首席执行官。我们测试了2006年这些规划特征与2003年两项财务绩效指标之间的关联。战略规划过程的三个维度——有战略计划、将计划责任交给首席执行官以及让董事会参与——与早期财务绩效呈正相关。需要进一步的纵向研究来评估规划与绩效之间的因果关系。