Marlowe Douglas B
Treatment Research Institute at the University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19106-3475, USA.
Sci Pract Perspect. 2003 Aug;2(1):4-14. doi: 10.1151/spp03214.
Proponents of a pure public safety perspective on the drug problem hold that drug-involved offenders require consistent and intensive supervision by criminal justice authorities in order to stay off drugs and out of trouble. In contrast, proponents of a thoroughgoing public health perspective commonly argue that clients perform better if they are left alone to develop an effective therapeutic alliance with counselors. Both may be correct, but with respect to different groups of offenders. One approach has shown consistent promise for reducing drug use and criminal recidivism: an integrated public health-public safety strategy that combines community-based drug abuse treatment with ongoing criminal justice supervision. This article presents promising findings from programs implementing this strategy and discusses best treatment practices to meet the needs of both low-risk and high-risk clients.
对于毒品问题持纯粹公共安全观点的支持者认为,涉毒罪犯需要刑事司法当局持续且密集的监管,以便远离毒品并避免麻烦。相比之下,秉持全面公共卫生观点的支持者通常认为,如果让客户自行与咨询师建立有效的治疗联盟,他们的表现会更好。两者可能都正确,但针对的是不同群体的罪犯。有一种方法在减少吸毒和再次犯罪方面一直显示出前景:一种将基于社区的药物滥用治疗与持续的刑事司法监管相结合的公共卫生 - 公共安全综合战略。本文介绍了实施该战略的项目所取得的有前景的成果,并讨论了满足低风险和高风险客户需求的最佳治疗实践。