Vemulakonda Vijaya M, Sorensen Mathew D, Joyner Byron D
Department of Urology, University of Washington School of Medicine and Division of Pediatric Urology, Children's Hospital and Regional Medical Center, Seattle, Washington, USA.
J Urol. 2008 Aug;180(2):668-72. doi: 10.1016/j.juro.2008.04.030. Epub 2008 Jun 12.
The American population continues to increase in ethnic diversity. However, the medical work force has lagged behind these population trends. We evaluated the extent of diversity and perceived barriers to multicultural training in American urology programs.
A 25-question nonvalidated diversity questionnaire was distributed electronically to 112 American urology residency program directors.
A total of 62 program directors (55%) responded, representing all American Urological Association geographic regions nationwide. Of the respondents 92% were male and 90% were older than 40 years. During their residency 44% of respondents reported no female co-residents and 51% reported no co-residents of color. As faculty, 40% of respondents reported no female colleagues and 49% reported no colleagues of color. Of the respondents 75% identified no formal process to recruit faculty of color. With regard to current residency training 36% of respondents reported 1 or fewer female residents, 66% reported at least 1 black resident and 42% reported at least 1 Hispanic resident in their program. Of the respondents 75% stated that multicultural training is important for residents and 46% reported no barriers to multicultural training. However, 75% of program directors reported no formal multicultural program training.
Most urology program directors trained with few minority or female co-residents. This paucity of diversity has continued with current faculty members. Residents are increasingly diverse but few urology residency programs have a formal curriculum or mentors to address diversity issues. Therefore, current residency training may not encourage diversity at academic centers or adequately prepare residents to serve an increasingly diverse patient population.
美国人口的种族多样性持续增加。然而,医疗劳动力却落后于这些人口趋势。我们评估了美国泌尿外科项目中的多样性程度以及多元文化培训所感知到的障碍。
一份包含25个问题的未经验证的多样性调查问卷通过电子方式分发给112位美国泌尿外科住院医师项目主任。
共有62位项目主任(55%)做出回应,代表了美国泌尿外科学会在全国的所有地理区域。在受访者中,92%为男性,90%年龄超过40岁。在住院医师期间,44%的受访者表示没有女性住院医师同事,51%表示没有有色人种住院医师同事。作为教职员工,40%的受访者表示没有女性同事,49%表示没有有色人种同事。75%的受访者表示没有招募有色人种教职员工的正式程序。关于当前的住院医师培训,36%的受访者表示其项目中有1名或更少的女性住院医师,66%表示至少有1名黑人住院医师,42%表示至少有1名西班牙裔住院医师。75%的受访者表示多元文化培训对住院医师很重要,46%表示多元文化培训没有障碍。然而,75%的项目主任表示没有正式的多元文化项目培训。
大多数泌尿外科项目主任在培训期间很少有少数族裔或女性住院医师同事。当前的教职员工中这种多样性的匮乏依然存在。住院医师的多样性日益增加,但很少有泌尿外科住院医师项目有正式的课程或导师来解决多样性问题。因此,当前的住院医师培训可能无法鼓励学术中心的多样性,也无法充分让住院医师做好为日益多样化的患者群体服务的准备。