Taylor Rachel M, Gibson Faith, Franck Linda S
Paediatric Liver Centre, King's College Hospital NHS Foundation Trust, London.
J Clin Nurs. 2008 Jul;17(14):1823-33. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2702.2008.02379.x.
To critique existing concept analyses of quality of life and develop a definition applicable for young people with chronic illness.
Quality of life is a commonly used phrase but there is no universal definition. Five perspectives of quality of life have been proposed: sociological, economic, psychological, philosophical and ethical. However, health has emerged as an important but distinct perspective. The nursing profession has made a substantial contribution to the understanding of the interrelationship of health and quality of life.
Literature review.
A search on electronic databases to April 2007 was made using the terms 'quality of life' and 'concept analysis'. Papers were included in the review if they used a recognised method of concept analysis and were conducted by nurses. A new concept analysis was then performed specifically focusing on young people's experiences of living with chronic illness.
Eight concept analyses were identified, all of which had limitations. All the concept analyses were based on adult literature so did not take into consideration developmental changes, language level, or young people's construction of health and illness. The new concept analysis found that young people living with chronic illness generally view themselves and their lives in the same way as their healthy peers. While their aspirations are often constrained by illness and treatment the relationship between illness and life cannot be seen in isolation of development.
Previous definitions of quality of life derived from concept analyses with adult populations do not adequately represent the experience of young people with chronic illnesses, but can be made more specific by incorporating important attributes such as developmental stage and the importance of peer group and family.
The current analysis provides a clear definition of quality of life from the health perspective which is specific for use with young people with chronic illness to guide practice and research.
对现有的生活质量概念分析进行批判性评价,并制定一个适用于患有慢性病的年轻人的定义。
生活质量是一个常用术语,但尚无通用定义。生活质量已提出了五个视角:社会学、经济学、心理学、哲学和伦理学。然而,健康已成为一个重要但独特的视角。护理专业在理解健康与生活质量的相互关系方面做出了重大贡献。
文献综述。
使用“生活质量”和“概念分析”等术语对截至2007年4月的电子数据库进行检索。如果论文采用公认的概念分析方法且由护士撰写,则纳入综述。然后专门针对患有慢性病的年轻人的经历进行了一项新的概念分析。
识别出八项概念分析,所有这些分析都有局限性。所有概念分析均基于成人文献,因此未考虑发育变化、语言水平或年轻人对健康和疾病的认知。新的概念分析发现,患有慢性病的年轻人通常与健康同龄人对自己和生活的看法相同。虽然他们的愿望常常受到疾病和治疗的限制,但疾病与生活之间的关系不能脱离发育孤立看待。
以前从针对成年人群的概念分析中得出的生活质量定义不能充分代表患有慢性病的年轻人的经历,但通过纳入发育阶段、同龄人群体和家庭的重要性等重要属性可以使其更具体。
当前分析从健康视角提供了一个明确的生活质量定义,该定义专门用于患有慢性病的年轻人,以指导实践和研究。