Rotgé J-Y, Aouizerate B, Tignol J
Service de psychiatrie d'adultes, centre hospitalier Charles-Perrens, centre Carreire, université Bordeaux-2, 121, rue de la Béchade, 33076 Bordeaux, France.
Encephale. 2008 Apr;34(2):194-204. doi: 10.1016/j.encep.2007.07.003. Epub 2007 Oct 24.
The management of patients with first-episode psychosis (FEP) is a difficult, but challenging task. Early and efficient treatment may influence long-term clinical outcome. Atypical antipsychotics (A-AP) are commonly prescribed in this population, but few data exist to establish their appropriate usage in the management of FEP. Our purpose is to review the literature and to summarize current data on the prescription of A-AP in FEP.
Studies assessing efficacy or safety of A-AP in FEP were identified by searches in Medline (up to April 2006). The following nine drugs were considered for this review: clozapine, olanzapine, risperidone, amisulpride, aripiprazole, quetiapine, ziprasidone, zotepine, and sertindole.
Only four A-AP (clozapine, quetiapine, olanzapine, and risperidone) were evaluated as treatment of FEP. All of them show the same efficacy as conventional antipsychotics (C-AP). Clozapine has no benefit over C-AP in the treatment of naive patients. It entails a high rate of treatment discontinuation because of the need for regular white blood cell monitoring explained by the risk of agranulocytosis. Hence, clozapine may not be a first-line treatment of FEP. Tolerance to quetiapine and olanzapine is better than C-AP regarding extrapyramidal side effects, but weight gain induced by these two A-AP may be very disabling in a young population. Considering results from head-to-head comparative studies, olanzapine may be more effective than risperidone when an affective component is associated with the FEP symptomatology, but more data are needed to demonstrate this point. Risperidone is a relatively well-tolerated compound when it is prescribed at doses lower than 4 mg/d. It is the only A-AP that showed greater efficacy than C-AP to prevent relapse in patients with FEP. Unfortunately, information regarding the preventive efficacy of the other A-AP are lacking.
Further studies, particularly longer-term studies, are needed to explore the impact of A-AP prescription in FEP on the course of psychotic disorders. The common use of A-AP as treatment of FEP is justified by a relatively better tolerance compared to C-AP, and by the hypothesis-not demonstrated-of a better effect on long-term outcome.
首发精神病(FEP)患者的管理是一项艰巨但具有挑战性的任务。早期且有效的治疗可能会影响长期临床结局。非典型抗精神病药物(A-AP)常用于该人群,但关于其在FEP管理中的恰当使用的数据却很少。我们的目的是回顾文献并总结目前关于FEP中A-AP处方的现有数据。
通过检索Medline(截至2006年4月)来识别评估A-AP在FEP中的疗效或安全性的研究。本次综述考虑了以下九种药物:氯氮平、奥氮平、利培酮、氨磺必利、阿立哌唑、喹硫平、齐拉西酮、佐替平以及舍吲哚。
仅四种A-AP(氯氮平、喹硫平、奥氮平和利培酮)被评估用于FEP的治疗。它们均显示出与传统抗精神病药物(C-AP)相同的疗效。氯氮平在治疗初治患者方面并不优于C-AP。由于粒细胞缺乏症风险需要定期监测白细胞,其导致治疗中断率较高。因此,氯氮平可能不是FEP的一线治疗药物。在锥体外系副作用方面,喹硫平和奥氮平的耐受性优于C-AP,但这两种A-AP引起的体重增加在年轻人群中可能非常严重。考虑到直接比较研究的结果,当FEP症状伴有情感成分时,奥氮平可能比利培酮更有效,但需要更多数据来证明这一点。当利培酮以低于4mg/d的剂量处方时,它是一种耐受性相对较好的药物。它是唯一一种在预防FEP患者复发方面显示出比C-AP更高效的A-AP。不幸的是,缺乏关于其他A-AP预防疗效的信息。
需要进一步的研究,尤其是长期研究,以探索FEP中A-AP处方对精神障碍病程的影响。与C-AP相比,A-AP相对较好的耐受性以及(尚未得到证实的)对长期结局有更好影响的假设,证明了将A-AP普遍用于FEP治疗的合理性。