Linder Stephen H, Marko Dritana, Sexton Ken
Institute for Health Policy, E-1023, The University of Texas School of Public Health, 1200 Herman Pressler Street, Houston, Texas 77030, USA.
Environ Sci Technol. 2008 Jun 15;42(12):4312-22. doi: 10.1021/es072042u.
Air toxics are of particular concern in Greater Houston, home to one of the world's largest petrochemical complexes and a quarter ofthe nation's refining capacity. Much of this complex lies along a navigable ship channel that flows 50 miles from east of the central business district through Galveston Bay and into the Gulf of Mexico. Numerous communities, including both poor and affluent neighborhoods, are located in close proximity to the 200 facilities along this channel. Our aim is to examine the spatial distribution of cumulative, air-pollution-related cancer risks in Houston and Harris County, with particular emphasis on identifying ethnic, economic, and social disparities. We employ exposure estimates from NATA-1999 and census data to assess whether the cumulative cancer risks from air toxics in Houston (and Harris County) fall disproportionately on certain ethnicities and on the socially and economically disadvantaged. The cancer risk burden across Harris County census tracts increases with the proportion of residents who are Hispanic and with key indicators of relative social disadvantage. Aggregate disadvantage grows at each higher level of cancer risk. The highest cancer risk in Harris County is concentrated along a corridor flanking the ship channel. These high-risk neighborhoods, however, vary markedly in relative disadvantage, as well as in emission source mix. Much of the risk they face appears to be driven by only a few hazardous air pollutants. Results provide evidence of risk disparities from hazardous air pollution based on ethnicity and social disadvantage. At the highest levels of risk the pattern is more complex, arguing for a neighborhood level of analysis, especially when proximity to high-emissions industries is a substantial contributor to cumulative cancer risk.
空气有毒物质在大休斯顿地区尤其令人担忧,该地区拥有世界上最大的石化综合设施之一,以及全国四分之一的炼油能力。这个综合设施的大部分位于一条可通航的船舶航道沿线,该航道从中央商务区以东50英里处流经加尔维斯顿湾,然后进入墨西哥湾。众多社区,包括贫困和富裕社区,都紧邻这条航道沿线的200家设施。我们的目标是研究休斯顿和哈里斯县与空气污染相关的累积癌症风险的空间分布,特别着重于识别种族、经济和社会差异。我们利用1999年国家空气有毒物质评估(NATA)的暴露估计值和人口普查数据,来评估休斯顿(和哈里斯县)空气中有毒物质造成的累积癌症风险是否不成比例地落在某些种族以及社会和经济弱势群体身上。哈里斯县各人口普查区的癌症风险负担随着西班牙裔居民的比例以及相对社会劣势的关键指标而增加。在癌症风险的每一个更高水平上,总体劣势都在增加。哈里斯县最高的癌症风险集中在船舶航道两侧的一条走廊沿线。然而,这些高风险社区在相对劣势以及排放源组合方面差异显著。它们面临的许多风险似乎仅由少数几种有害空气污染物驱动。结果提供了基于种族和社会劣势的有害空气污染导致风险差异的证据。在最高风险水平上,情况更为复杂,这表明需要进行社区层面的分析,尤其是当靠近高排放行业是累积癌症风险的一个重要因素时。