Brenneman Michele H, Decker Scott, Meyers Joel, Johnson Katrina
Georgia State University, Atlanta, GA, USA.
Laterality. 2008 Nov;13(6):481-503. doi: 10.1080/13576500802164133. Epub 2008 Jun 6.
The purpose of this research was to investigate the relationship between handedness, reading skills, and reading-related cognitive processes. Although lateralised differences in brain functioning are well known, research regarding handedness, specific reading skills, and reading-related cognitive processes is ambiguous at best because handedness is often measured as a dichotomous variable rather than a continuous variable. This methodological difference contributes to the diverse research findings, therefore the present investigation addressed these methodological limitations. A large normative sample of up to 1383 participants who ranged in age from 4 to 80 completed the Woodcock Johnson Psycho-Educational Battery-Revised (Woodcock & Johnson, 1989a, 1989b) or the Woodcock Johnson Psycho-Educational Battery-Third Edition (Woodcock, McGrew, & Mather, 2001) in combination with the Dean Woodcock Sensory Motor Battery (Dean & Woodcock, 2003) lateral preference scale, a continuous measure of handedness. Polynomial multiple regression analyses indicated curvilinear relationships between handedness and reading skills, along with handedness and auditory working memory. Individuals towards the extremes of the handedness continuum performed less well on the reading-related tasks. Therefore, just knowing a general classification of right, left, or mixed handed will not provide significant knowledge regarding lateralisation or potential cognitive and academic consequences but rather knowledge of an individual's hand preference on a continuum may well be useful for evaluative purposes.
本研究的目的是调查用手习惯、阅读技能和与阅读相关的认知过程之间的关系。尽管大脑功能的偏侧化差异已广为人知,但关于用手习惯、特定阅读技能和与阅读相关的认知过程的研究充其量也只是模糊不清,因为用手习惯通常被测量为一个二分变量而非连续变量。这种方法上的差异导致了多样的研究结果,因此本调查解决了这些方法上的局限性。一个由多达1383名年龄在4岁至80岁之间的参与者组成的大型常模样本,完成了伍德库克-约翰逊心理教育成套测验修订版(伍德库克和约翰逊,1989a,1989b)或伍德库克-约翰逊心理教育成套测验第三版(伍德库克、麦格鲁和马瑟,2001),并结合了迪恩·伍德库克感觉运动成套测验(迪恩和伍德库克,2003)的用手偏好量表,这是一种对用手习惯的连续测量。多项式多元回归分析表明,用手习惯与阅读技能之间以及用手习惯与听觉工作记忆之间存在曲线关系。处于用手习惯连续体两端的个体在与阅读相关的任务上表现较差。因此,仅仅知道右利手、左利手或混合利手的一般分类,并不能提供关于偏侧化或潜在认知及学业后果的重要信息,而了解个体在连续体上的用手偏好很可能对评估目的有用。