Williams David Michael, Bentley Rob, Cobourne Martyn T, Gibilaro Anna, Good Sarah, Huppa Christoph, Matthews Nigel Shaun, O'Higgins Liz, Patel Shruti, Newton Jonathon Timothy
Department of Oral Health Research Services and Dental Public Health, Dental Institute, King's College London, Denmark Hill Campus, Caldecot Road, Denmark Hill, London SE5 9RW, United Kingdom.
J Dent. 2008 Sep;36(9):711-7. doi: 10.1016/j.jdent.2008.05.002. Epub 2008 Jul 18.
Recent work has demonstrated that female orthognathic patients display more dissatisfaction with their facial appearance after viewing idealised images of facial photographs, than do controls. Patients may request orthognathic surgery because they hope to improve their appearance to conform with ideals portrayed in the mass media, and these hopes may not be realistic. Patients who demonstrate certain personality traits are more likely to hold such hopes. The current study sought to identify the role of dental status (orthognathic patient versus control), personality traits and media images in dissatisfaction with facial appearance.
Female patients and controls completed a bank of personality measures and then gave repeated measures of satisfaction with their facial appearance after viewing images of 'ideal' and 'average' women.
Neither group showed any change in satisfaction with appearance after viewing either set of images. Patients showed lower satisfaction with facial appearance than controls, but did not differ on other personality measures.
Viewing 'ideal' images of other women has no significant impact on satisfaction with appearance compared to viewing images of 'average' women. These results may help inform the development of a psycho-educational intervention to protect women against the negative effects of viewing idealised images in the media.
近期研究表明,与对照组相比,女性正颌患者在观看面部照片的理想化图像后,对自己的面部外观表现出更多不满。患者可能会要求进行正颌手术,因为他们希望改善自己的外貌以符合大众媒体所描绘的理想形象,而这些希望可能并不现实。表现出某些人格特质的患者更有可能抱有此类希望。当前研究旨在确定牙齿状况(正颌患者与对照组)、人格特质和媒体图像在对面部外观不满方面所起的作用。
女性患者和对照组完成了一系列人格测试,然后在观看“理想”和“普通”女性的图像后,多次测量她们对自己面部外观的满意度。
两组在观看任何一组图像后,对面部外观的满意度均未出现任何变化。患者对面部外观的满意度低于对照组,但在其他人格测试方面没有差异。
与观看“普通”女性的图像相比,观看其他女性的“理想”图像对外观满意度没有显著影响。这些结果可能有助于为制定心理教育干预措施提供参考,以保护女性免受观看媒体中理想化图像的负面影响。