Goadsby P J
Headache Group, Department of Neurology, University of California, San Francisco, San Francisco, CA, USA.
Cephalalgia. 2008 Sep;28 Suppl 2:36-41. doi: 10.1111/j.1468-2982.2008.01689.x.
An important issue in the management of migraine is the advice given to patients as to when to take their treatment in the course of the attack. While it seems common sense almost to take treatment early in the attack, the evidence base for that advice is not as robust as could be expected. The 'Act when Mild' (AwM) Study was a randomized, four-arm, multicentre, multinational, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial of almotriptan (12.5 mg) to compare outcomes after administration of treatment when pain intensity was mild and within 1 h of headache onset (mild/early) with outcomes when pain had become moderate or severe. Of 491 migraineurs enrolled, 403 were evaluable with an intention-to-treat population (ITT) of 404. At the primary end-point, 2 h pain free, on the ITT analysis 49% of patients in the almotriptan 12.5 mg treat early/mild group and 40% in the treat moderate/severe group had responded (P = 0.21). Of these patients, 43 did not take medication according to their randomly allocated baseline pain intensity (mild or moderate/severe) and were subsequently reassigned, prior to study unblinding, to the appropriate group (AwM population) for re-analysis of the primary outcome measure: 2-h pain-free rates. In the almotriptan arms, 53% of the mild/early group and 37.5% of the moderate/severe group were pain free at 2 h (P = 0.02; AwM population). The corresponding proportions in the placebo groups were 24.7% and 17.5% (significantly lower than the respective almotriptan arms; P </= 0.01). Considering the ITT population, secondary end-points were also significantly in favour of treatment with almotriptan in the mild/early vs. the moderate/severe stage, including: sustained pain-free, 45.6% vs. 30.5% (P = 0.02); headache recurrence at 24 h, 6% vs. 24% (P = 0.0124). Adverse events were reported in < 5% of patients, with no significant differences between almotriptan and placebo and no serious events in any group. Treatment with almotriptan while migraine pain is still mild and within 1 h of onset provides statistically significant and clinically relevant enhancements in efficacy compared with waiting until pain has reached higher severity levels.
偏头痛管理中的一个重要问题是就发作过程中何时进行治疗向患者提供的建议。虽然在发作早期进行治疗似乎是常识,但该建议的证据基础并不像预期的那样有力。“轻度发作时用药”(AwM)研究是一项随机、四臂、多中心、跨国、双盲、安慰剂对照试验,比较了阿莫曲坦(12.5毫克)在疼痛强度为轻度且在头痛发作1小时内(轻度/早期)给药后的结果与疼痛已变为中度或重度时给药后的结果。在纳入的491名偏头痛患者中,403名可评估,意向性治疗人群(ITT)为404名。在主要终点,即2小时无疼痛方面,在意向性治疗分析中,阿莫曲坦12.5毫克早期/轻度治疗组49%的患者和中度/重度治疗组40%的患者有反应(P = 0.21)。在这些患者中,43名未根据随机分配的基线疼痛强度(轻度或中度/重度)服药,随后在研究揭盲前被重新分配到适当的组(AwM人群),以重新分析主要结局指标:2小时无疼痛率。在阿莫曲坦组中,轻度/早期组53%的患者和中度/重度组37.5%的患者在2小时时无疼痛(P = 0.02;AwM人群)。安慰剂组的相应比例为24.7%和17.5%(显著低于各自的阿莫曲坦组;P≤0.01)。考虑意向性治疗人群,次要终点在轻度/早期与中度/重度阶段也显著有利于阿莫曲坦治疗,包括:持续无疼痛,45.6%对30.5%(P = 0.02);24小时头痛复发,6%对24%(P = 0.0124)。不到5%的患者报告了不良事件,阿莫曲坦和安慰剂之间无显著差异,任何组均无严重事件。与等到疼痛达到更高严重程度水平相比,在偏头痛疼痛仍为轻度且发作1小时内使用阿莫曲坦治疗在疗效上具有统计学显著且临床相关的提高。