Pascual Julio, González-Mandly Andrés, Martín Rubén, Oterino Agustín
Service of Neurology, University Hospital of Salamanca, 37007, Salamanca, Spain.
J Headache Pain. 2008 Oct;9(5):259-66. doi: 10.1007/s10194-008-0063-5. Epub 2008 Aug 28.
Headaches provoked by cough, prolonged physical exercise and sexual activity have not been studied prospectively, clinically and neuroradiologically. Our aim was to delimitate characteristics, etiology, response to treatment and neuroradiological diagnostic protocol of those patients who consult to a general Neurological Department because of provoked headache. Those patients who consulted due to provoked headaches between 1996 and 2006 were interviewed in depth and followed-up for at least 1 year. Neuroradiological protocol included cranio-cervical MRI for all patients with cough headache and dynamic cerebrospinal functional MRI in secondary cough headache cases. In patients with headache provoked by prolonged physical exercise or/and sexual activity cranial neuroimaging (CT and/or MRI) was performed and, in case of suspicion of subarachnoid bleeding, angioMRI and/or lumbar tap were carried out. A total of 6,412 patients consulted due to headache during the 10 years of the study. The number of patients who had consulted due to any of these headaches is 97 (1.5% of all headaches). Diagnostic distribution was as follows: 68 patients (70.1%) consulted due to cough headache, 11 (11.3%) due to exertional headache and 18 (18.6%) due to sexual headache. A total of 28 patients (41.2%) out of 68 were diagnosed of primary cough headache, while the remaining 40 (58.8%) had secondary cough headache, always due to structural lesions in the posterior fossa, which in most cases was a Chiari type I malformation. In seven patients, cough headache was precipitated by treatment with angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors. As compared to the primary variety, secondary cough headache began earlier (average 40 vs. 60 years old), was located posteriorly, lasted longer (5 years vs. 11 months), was associated with posterior fossa symptoms/signs and did not respond to indomethacin. All those patients showed difficulties in the cerebrospinal fluid circulation in the foramen magnum region in the dynamic MRI study and preoperative plateau waves, which disappeared after posterior fossa reconstruction. The mean age at onset for primary headaches provoked by physical exercise and sexual activity began at the same age (40 years old), shared clinical characteristics (bilateral, pulsating) and responded to beta-blockers. Contrary to cough headache, secondary cases are rare and the most frequent etiology was subarachnoid bleeding. In conclusion, these conditions account for a low proportion of headache consultations. These data show the total separation between cough headache versus headache due to physical exercise and sexual activity, confirm that these two latter headaches are clinical variants of the same entity and illustrate the clinical differences between the primary and secondary provoked headaches.
由咳嗽、长时间体育锻炼和性活动引发的头痛尚未进行前瞻性、临床和神经放射学研究。我们的目的是界定那些因引发性头痛而到普通神经科就诊的患者的特征、病因、治疗反应及神经放射学诊断方案。对1996年至2006年间因引发性头痛前来就诊的患者进行了深入访谈,并随访至少1年。神经放射学检查方案包括对所有咳嗽性头痛患者进行颅颈MRI检查,对继发性咳嗽性头痛患者进行动态脑脊液功能MRI检查。对于因长时间体育锻炼或/和性活动引发头痛的患者,进行头颅神经影像学检查(CT和/或MRI),怀疑有蛛网膜下腔出血时,进行血管造影MRI和/或腰椎穿刺。在研究的10年中,共有6412例患者因头痛前来就诊。因这些头痛中的任何一种前来就诊的患者有97例(占所有头痛患者的1.5%)。诊断分布如下:68例(70.1%)因咳嗽性头痛就诊,11例(11.3%)因运动性头痛就诊,18例(18.6%)因性头痛就诊。68例患者中共有28例(41.2%)被诊断为原发性咳嗽性头痛,其余40例(58.8%)为继发性咳嗽性头痛,均由后颅窝结构性病变引起,大多数情况下是Chiari I型畸形。7例患者的咳嗽性头痛是由血管紧张素转换酶抑制剂治疗诱发的。与原发性类型相比,继发性咳嗽性头痛起病更早(平均40岁对60岁),位于后部,持续时间更长(5年对11个月),伴有后颅窝症状/体征,对吲哚美辛无反应。所有这些患者在动态MRI研究中均显示枕大孔区脑脊液循环困难及术前平台波,后颅窝重建后消失。因体育锻炼和性活动引发的原发性头痛的平均起病年龄相同(40岁),具有共同的临床特征(双侧、搏动性),对β受体阻滞剂有反应。与咳嗽性头痛相反,继发性病例罕见,最常见的病因是蛛网膜下腔出血。总之,这些情况在头痛就诊患者中所占比例较低。这些数据表明咳嗽性头痛与因体育锻炼和性活动引发的头痛完全不同,证实后两种头痛是同一实体的临床变体,并说明了原发性和继发性引发性头痛的临床差异。