Skie Martin C, Gove Nicholas, Ciocanel Despina E, Smith Holly
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University of Toledo-Health Science Campus, 3065 Arlington Ave, Dowling Hall, Toledo, Ohio, 43614, USA.
Hand (N Y). 2007 Mar;2(1):34-8. doi: 10.1007/s11552-007-9021-y.
Wrist degeneration, resulting from scaphoid nonunion or scapholunate ligamentous disruption, is widely managed with scaphoid excision with four-corner fusion. There are no specific details in the literature regarding "salvage" of nonunion after attempted "four-corner fusions" or the patient outcomes. The purpose of this paper is to present the results of patients who underwent treatment for nonunion after four-corner fusion, the subsequent surgeries done for wrist salvage and the functional results.
We reviewed, retrospectively, 37 patients who underwent limited wrist fusion using circular plate fixation, of which eight cases (22%) went on to nonunion and necessitated revision surgeries with plate exchange and bone graft. (Table 1) Five of eight patients were available to return to the clinic, and the wrist range of motion and the disabilities of the arm, shoulder, and hand (DASH) score were recorded.
The average DASH score was 46 (range, 15 to 60.8). Grip on the affected limb was, on the average, 62% of the contralateral limb. Average arc of wrist motion was 70 degrees (35.7 degrees of flexion and 34.3 degrees of extension). Three of the five patients were laborers, and two returned to the previous employment. The remaining two patients returned to their previous sedentary jobs. All patients reported difficulty with recreational activities involving heavy activity.
Complications of four-corner arthrodesis using circular plate fixation were recorded, revealing a high number of nonunions and hardware failures. All nonunions were salvaged with allograft or autogenous grafting with plate revision; however, the patients did have considerable limitations.
舟骨不愈合或舟月韧带断裂导致的腕关节退变,广泛采用舟骨切除四角融合术进行治疗。关于尝试进行“四角融合”后不愈合的“挽救”措施或患者预后,文献中尚无具体细节。本文旨在介绍接受四角融合术后不愈合治疗的患者结果、随后为挽救腕关节所做的手术以及功能结果。
我们回顾性分析了37例行环形钢板固定有限腕关节融合术的患者,其中8例(22%)出现不愈合,需要进行钢板更换和植骨的翻修手术。(表1)8例患者中有5例返回诊所,记录了腕关节活动范围和上肢、肩部及手部功能障碍(DASH)评分。
平均DASH评分为46分(范围为15至60.8分)。患侧肢体的握力平均为对侧肢体的62%。腕关节平均活动弧度为70度(屈曲35.7度,伸展34.3度)。5例患者中有3例为体力劳动者,2例恢复了之前的工作。其余2例患者恢复了之前的久坐工作。所有患者均表示在涉及剧烈活动的娱乐活动中存在困难。
记录了使用环形钢板固定进行四角关节融合术的并发症,显示不愈合和内固定失败的发生率较高。所有不愈合均通过同种异体骨移植或自体骨移植及钢板翻修得以挽救;然而,患者确实存在相当大的局限性。