Hofer S, Oberholzer C, Beck S, Looser C, Ludwig C
Oncology, Claraspital, Basel.
Ultraschall Med. 2008 Aug;29(4):388-92. doi: 10.1055/s-2008-1027197.
Surgery is the most effective treatment for liver metastases. Some patients, however, cannot tolerate this procedure due to co-morbidity, advanced age, site of the lesion or previous liver surgery. In our institution we have now increasing experience with radiofrequency ablation (RFA), a thermo-ablative modality. We compare our outcome and survival results to standard treatments for liver metastases.
From April 2000 to June 2005, 30 consecutive patients with liver metastases from gastrointestinal primaries were treated with ultrasound guided RFA for their liver metastases (patients mean age 63.5 years, range 37-80. Size of lesions, range 0.4-6 cm). Main indications were non-operable lesions due to site of the lesion or co-morbidity. RFA was also applied as an additive to liver surgery and as a repetitive palliative treatment. 15 patients underwent one RFA-intervention, 8 patients two, 3 patients three, 1 patient four, 2 patients five and 1 patient six. RFA-interventions (n = 60) were performed either percutaneously (71.5%), in an open approach without liver surgery (22%) or in addition to liver surgery (6.5%).
Mean observation time after first RFA was 23.5 months (range 3-63). Median survival in our patient cohort is 34 months, which compares favourably with results obtained by hepatic resection, the standard of care for liver metastases. Complication rate, attributed to the RFA procedure, was small in our series (5.5%) with one pleural effusion and one abscess formation in the ablated lesion due to underlying bacteraemia.
RFA is an effective and low risk treatment modality in patients with liver metastases. The procedure is safe (complication rate < 6%) with low morbidity. RFA can be performed repeatedly on an outpatient basis with good palliative effects. Of note, surgery remains the treatment of choice in resectable liver metastases of colorectal origin.
手术是治疗肝转移瘤最有效的方法。然而,一些患者由于合并症、高龄、病变部位或既往肝脏手术史而无法耐受该手术。在我们机构,我们现在对射频消融(RFA)这一热消融方式有了越来越多的经验。我们将我们的治疗结果和生存结果与肝转移瘤的标准治疗方法进行比较。
从2000年4月至2005年6月,30例连续的胃肠道原发性肿瘤肝转移患者接受了超声引导下的RFA治疗肝转移瘤(患者平均年龄63.5岁,范围37 - 80岁。病变大小,范围0.4 - 6厘米)。主要适应证为因病变部位或合并症而无法手术的病变。RFA也作为肝脏手术的辅助治疗以及重复的姑息治疗应用。15例患者接受了1次RFA治疗,8例患者接受了2次,3例患者接受了3次,1例患者接受了4次,2例患者接受了5次,1例患者接受了6次。RFA治疗(n = 60)通过经皮方式进行(71.5%)、在未进行肝脏手术的开放方式下进行(22%)或作为肝脏手术的辅助进行(6.5%)。
首次RFA后的平均观察时间为23.5个月(范围3 - 63个月)。我们患者队列的中位生存期为34个月,与肝转移瘤的标准治疗方法肝切除所获得的结果相比具有优势。在我们的系列研究中,归因于RFA治疗的并发症发生率较低(5.5%),因潜在菌血症导致1例胸腔积液和1例消融病变处脓肿形成。
RFA是肝转移瘤患者一种有效且低风险的治疗方式。该手术安全(并发症发生率<6%),发病率低。RFA可在门诊反复进行,具有良好的姑息效果。值得注意的是,手术仍然是可切除的结直肠癌肝转移的首选治疗方法。