Tsaiweichao-Shozawa Yasunobu, Sonoo Masahiro, Shimizu Teruo
From the Department of Neurology, Teikyo University School of Medicine, Tokyo, Japan.
J Clin Neurophysiol. 2008 Oct;25(5):281-6. doi: 10.1097/WNP.0b013e3181879d42.
Nerve conduction study findings in severe carpal tunnel syndrome have seldom been systematically investigated. The authors determined the persistence of each nerve conduction study parameter in severe carpal tunnel syndrome. Subjects were prospectively-collected 30 hands from 23 carpal tunnel syndrome patients, with an orthodromic sensory nerve action potential (SNAP) amplitude of the median nerve of 1 muV or less, or with an compound muscle action potentials (CMAPs) of the abductor pollicis brevis (APB) of 2 mV or less. Compound muscle action potentials of APB and second lumbricalis (2L) and orthodromic and antidromic SNAPs at the index finger were measured. As results, 2L-CMAP was obtainable for all but one hand, APB-CMAP for 20, orthodromic SNAP for 18, and antidromic SNAP for 13 hands. Four hands with preserved APB-CMAPs lacked SNAPs, whereas three hands with preserved orthodromic or antidromic SNAPs lacked APB-CMAPs. The mixed-nerve action potential at the wrist following orthodromic palm stimulation was identified in only 3 of 18 hands investigated. Orthodromic SNAP has an advantage that contamination by CMAPs is entirely lacking, and the authors documented its much higher persistence than previous studies because of their more detailed methods. Such different criteria of no response of SNAP between researchers should be taken notice in the grading system of carpal tunnel syndrome.
严重腕管综合征的神经传导研究结果很少得到系统研究。作者确定了严重腕管综合征中每个神经传导研究参数的持续性。前瞻性收集了23例腕管综合征患者的30只手,正中神经的顺向感觉神经动作电位(SNAP)幅度为1μV或更低,或拇短展肌(APB)的复合肌肉动作电位(CMAP)为2mV或更低。测量了APB和第二蚓状肌(2L)的复合肌肉动作电位以及示指处的顺向和逆向SNAP。结果显示,除一只手外,其余所有手均可获得2L-CMAP,20只手可获得APB-CMAP,18只手可获得顺向SNAP,13只手可获得逆向SNAP。4只保留APB-CMAP的手没有SNAP,而3只保留顺向或逆向SNAP的手没有APB-CMAP。在18只被研究的手中,只有3只在顺向刺激手掌后在腕部检测到混合神经动作电位。顺向SNAP的优点是完全没有CMAP的干扰,并且由于作者采用了更详细的方法,记录到其持续性比以前的研究高得多。在腕管综合征的分级系统中,应注意研究人员之间SNAP无反应的不同标准。