Muzykewicz David A, Costello Daniel J, Halpern Elkan F, Thiele Elizabeth A
Department of Neurology, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts 02114, USA.
Epilepsia. 2009 Feb;50(2):290-6. doi: 10.1111/j.1528-1167.2008.01788.x. Epub 2008 Sep 17.
To assess cognitive and epilepsy outcomes in tuberous sclerosis complex (TSC) patients with a history of infantile spasms (IS), in relation to spasm history, electroencephalography (EEG) characteristics, genetic mutation, and treatment history.
The authors conducted a retrospective review of 45 children and adults with TSC and a history of IS. EEG reports from the time of spasms were evaluated for all patients, and EEG tracings were accessible and evaluated for 20 patients.
Clinical outcome was unfavorable for the majority of patients. However, 33% had experienced at least one year of seizure freedom at follow-up, and 24% of those tested had IQs above 70. Hypsarrhythmia severity scores varied widely, with some EEGs severely hypsarrhythmic and others essentially normal. Lower IQ was significantly associated with higher hypsarrhythmia severity scores on EEG report, the presence of background disorganization on EEG report, the absence of normal sleep patterns on EEG, and a lower degree of treatment success on vigabatrin. A relationship between poor cognitive outcome and poor epilepsy outcome was confirmed. The correlation between poor epilepsy outcome and a greater degree of background disorganization on EEG approached significance, as did the association between subsequent intractable epilepsy and an older age at IS cessation. A greater than expected ratio of TSC2 to TSC1 patients was observed across this IS population.
Early detection and successful treatment portend a more favorable outcome in TSC patients with IS. Although EEG findings in these patients vary, specific characteristics may serve as clinically useful prognostic markers.
评估有婴儿痉挛症(IS)病史的结节性硬化症(TSC)患者的认知和癫痫结局,分析其与痉挛病史、脑电图(EEG)特征、基因突变及治疗史的关系。
作者对45例有TSC病史且曾患IS的儿童和成人进行了回顾性研究。对所有患者痉挛发作时的EEG报告进行评估,其中20例患者的EEG记录可供查阅并进行分析。
大多数患者的临床结局不佳。然而,33%的患者在随访中至少有1年无癫痫发作,且接受测试的患者中有24%的智商高于70。高峰失律严重程度评分差异很大,有些EEG显示严重的高峰失律,而另一些则基本正常。较低的智商与EEG报告中较高的高峰失律严重程度评分、EEG报告中存在背景紊乱、EEG上无正常睡眠模式以及氨己烯酸治疗成功率较低显著相关。认知结局差与癫痫结局差之间的关系得到证实。癫痫结局差与EEG上背景紊乱程度较高之间的相关性接近显著水平,后续难治性癫痫与IS停止时年龄较大之间的关联也接近显著水平。在整个IS患者群体中,观察到TSC2患者与TSC1患者的比例高于预期。
早期发现和成功治疗预示着有IS的TSC患者有更良好的结局。尽管这些患者的EEG表现各异,但特定特征可能作为临床上有用的预后指标。