Duijm Lucien E M, Overbosch Evert H, Liem Ylian S, Planken Robrecht N, Tordoir Jan H M, Cuypers Philippe W M, Douwes-Draaijer Petra, de Haan Michiel W
Department of Radiology, Catharina Hospital, Michelangelolaan 2, 5623 EJ, Eindhoven, The Netherlands.
Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2009 Feb;24(2):539-47. doi: 10.1093/ndt/gfn526. Epub 2008 Sep 18.
The European Best Practice Guidelines on Vascular Access propose magnetic resonance angiography (MRA) of dysfunctional dialysis fistulae and grafts if visualization of the complete arterial inflow and outflow vessels is needed. In a prospective multi-centre study we determined the technical success rate of complete vascular access tree depiction by digital subtraction angiography (DSA) as an alternative to MRA. Instead of a more invasive brachial artery of femoral artery approach, we performed a retrograde catheterization of the venous outflow or graft, and stenoses were treated in connection with DSA.
A catheter was advanced into the central arterial inflow after retrograde puncture of the venous outflow or graft for depiction of the complete inflow, access region and complete outflow. Access DSA through femoral artery puncture was done if the retrograde approach failed to depict the complete vascular access tree. Stenoses with a luminal diameter reduction >or=50% were treated, if possible, in connection with DSA.
A total of 116 dysfunctional haemodialysis fistulae and 50 grafts were included. Retrograde DSA depicted the complete vascular tree in 162 patients (97.6%). The arteriovenous anastomosis of four fistulae could not be negotiated by a catheter. DSA demonstrated 247 significant stenoses: 30, 128 and 89 were located in the arterial inflow (12.1%), AV anastomosis and graft region (51.8%) and venous outflow (36.0%), respectively. Ten patients (6.0%) had no stenosis. Eight (4.8%), 55 (33.1%) and 33 (19.9%) patients demonstrated stenoses in only inflow, access region or outflow, respectively. Stenoses in two or three vascular territories were present in 53 (31.9%) and 7 (4.2%) patients, respectively. A technically successful endovascular intervention was obtained in 135 of the 139 patients (97.1%) who underwent angioplasty and/or stent placement. Additional sheath insertion by antegrade outflow puncture was needed in 46 patients (33.1%) for the treatment of coexisting venous outflow stenoses, located downstream from the retrograde positioned sheath. Two minor complications were observed at DSA/angioplasty.
As an alternative to MRA, full retrograde DSA is safe and effective for stenosis detection and stenosis treatment. However, access evaluation by a non-invasive imaging modality such as colour duplex ultrasound will be sufficient in most cases as proximal inflow stenoses are encountered in a minority of patients. Full retrograde DSA, including complete arterial inflow depiction, may then be reserved for cases with an unsuccessful outcome following endovascular intervention of stenoses depicted at ultrasound.
欧洲血管通路最佳实践指南建议,如果需要完整显示动脉流入和流出血管,则对功能障碍的透析内瘘和移植物进行磁共振血管造影(MRA)。在一项前瞻性多中心研究中,我们确定了通过数字减影血管造影(DSA)完整描绘血管通路树的技术成功率,以替代MRA。我们未采用更具侵入性的肱动脉或股动脉入路,而是对静脉流出道或移植物进行逆行插管,并在DSA的同时治疗狭窄。
在对静脉流出道或移植物进行逆行穿刺后,将导管推进至中心动脉流入道,以描绘完整的流入道、通路区域和完整的流出道。如果逆行入路未能描绘完整的血管通路树,则通过股动脉穿刺进行通路DSA。如果可能,在DSA的同时治疗管腔直径缩小≥50%的狭窄。
共纳入116个功能障碍的血液透析内瘘和50个移植物。逆行DSA在162例患者(97.6%)中描绘了完整的血管树。4个内瘘的动静脉吻合口无法通过导管通过。DSA显示247处明显狭窄:分别有30处、128处和89处位于动脉流入道(12.1%)、动静脉吻合口和移植物区域(51.8%)以及静脉流出道(36.0%)。10例患者(6.0%)无狭窄。分别有8例(4.8%)、55例(33.1%)和