Lee Kyung-Bok, Kim Dong-Ik, Oh Se-Keon, Do Young-Soo, Kim Keon-Ha, Kim Young-Wook
Division of Vascular Surgery, Samsung Medical Center, Sungkyunkwan University School of Medicine, Seoul, South Korea.
J Vasc Surg. 2008 Nov;48(5):1286-91. doi: 10.1016/j.jvs.2008.06.058. Epub 2008 Oct 1.
Embolo/sclerotherapy is an important treatment modality for vascular malformations, but the rates and results of the complications associated with embolo/sclerotherapy are not well known. We report the incidence and outcome of soft tissue injury and neuropathy after performing embolo/sclerotherapy for congenital vascular malformations (CVMs) classified according to the Hamburg classification.
Among 1823 patients with CVM, 573 were treated with embolo/sclerotherapy. We retrospectively reviewed 68 patients (31 males, 37 females; mean age, 20.0 years) with soft tissue injury and 49 patients (16 males, 33 females; mean age, 21.2 years) with neuropathy. The indications for embolo/sclerotherapy for CVM were that the CVMs affected the quality of life, such as a symptomatic or trauma-prone lesion or a lesion that was impairing the function of a limb, and the lesions that were located near a life-threatening vital area, including the airway. As embolo/sclerotherapy agents, absolute or 80% ethanol, N-butyl cyanoacrylate (NBCA), and various types of coils or contour particles were used in various combinations, either at the same time or in phases, depending on the location, severity, and extent of the CVM.
The incidence of soft tissue injury was 29.4% (42 of 143) for the arteriovenous shunting type and 8% (22 of 273) for the venous type. No soft tissue injuries occurred in the patients with arterial and lymphatic malformations. Of the 68 patients with soft tissue injury, 40 lesions healed with conservative management, and 28 lesions needed surgery, including escharectomy, skin graft, or amputation. The incidence of neuropathy was 10.9% (30 of 273) for the venous CVM. No neuropathy occurred in the patients with arterial malformations. Of the 49 patients with neuropathy, 42 recovered at a mean period of 5.3 months, but seven did not.
Soft tissue injuries occurred in 11.9% of patients (68 of 573) and neuropathies occurred in 8.6% (49 of 573) after undergoing embolo/sclerotherapy. Most of these complications recovered by themselves (58.9% from soft tissue injury and 85.1% from neuropathy). Our results suggest that embolo/sclerotherapy has an acceptable incidence of soft tissue injury and neuropathy, when considering the effect that the CVM had on the quality of life before treatment, so embolo/sclerotherapy is recommended as a treatment modality for CVM.
栓塞/硬化治疗是血管畸形的一种重要治疗方式,但与栓塞/硬化治疗相关的并发症发生率和结果尚不清楚。我们报告了根据汉堡分类法对先天性血管畸形(CVM)进行栓塞/硬化治疗后软组织损伤和神经病变的发生率及结局。
在1823例CVM患者中,573例接受了栓塞/硬化治疗。我们回顾性分析了68例(男31例,女37例;平均年龄20.0岁)发生软组织损伤的患者和49例(男16例,女33例;平均年龄21.2岁)发生神经病变的患者。CVM栓塞/硬化治疗的适应证为CVM影响生活质量,如出现症状或易受创伤的病变,或损害肢体功能的病变,以及位于危及生命的重要区域(包括气道)附近的病变。作为栓塞/硬化治疗药物,根据CVM的位置、严重程度和范围,绝对乙醇或80%乙醇、氰基丙烯酸正丁酯(NBCA)以及各种类型的线圈或轮廓颗粒以不同组合同时或分阶段使用。
动静脉分流型软组织损伤发生率为29.4%(143例中的42例),静脉型为8%(273例中的22例)。动脉和淋巴管畸形患者未发生软组织损伤。68例软组织损伤患者中,40处病变经保守治疗愈合,28处病变需要手术治疗,包括焦痂切除术、植皮术或截肢术。静脉CVM患者神经病变发生率为10.9%(273例中的30例)。动脉畸形患者未发生神经病变。49例神经病变患者中,42例平均在5.3个月后恢复,但7例未恢复。
栓塞/硬化治疗后,11.9%(573例中的68例)的患者发生软组织损伤,8.6%(573例中的49例)的患者发生神经病变。这些并发症大多可自行恢复(软组织损伤为58.9%,神经病变为85.1%)。我们的结果表明,考虑到治疗前CVM对生活质量的影响,栓塞/硬化治疗的软组织损伤和神经病变发生率是可以接受的,因此推荐将栓塞/硬化治疗作为CVM的一种治疗方式。