Cook John T, Frank Deborah A, Casey Patrick H, Rose-Jacobs Ruth, Black Maureen M, Chilton Mariana, Ettinger de Cuba Stephanie, Appugliese Danielle, Coleman Sharon, Heeren Timothy, Berkowitz Carol, Cutts Diana B
Department of Pediatrics, Boston Medical Center, Boston, MA 02118, USA.
Pediatrics. 2008 Oct;122(4):e867-75. doi: 10.1542/peds.2008-0286.
Household energy security has not been measured empirically or related to child health and development but is an emerging concern for clinicians and researchers as energy costs increase. The objectives of this study were to develop a clinical indicator of household energy security and assess associations with food security, health, and developmental risk in children <36 months of age.
A cross-sectional study that used household survey and surveillance data was conducted. Caregivers were interviewed in emergency departments and primary care clinics form January 2001 through December 2006 on demographics, public assistance, food security, experience with heating/cooling and utilities, Parents Evaluation of Developmental Status, and child health. The household energy security indicator includes energy-secure, no energy problems; moderate energy insecurity, utility shutoff threatened in past year; and severe energy insecurity, heated with cooking stove, utility shutoff, or >or=1 day without heat/cooling in past year. The main outcome measures were household and child food security, child reported health status, Parents Evaluation of Developmental Status concerns, and hospitalizations.
Of 9721 children, 11% (n = 1043) and 23% (n = 2293) experienced moderate and severe energy insecurity, respectively. Versus children with energy security, children with moderate energy insecurity had greater odds of household food insecurity, child food insecurity, hospitalization since birth, and caregiver report of child fair/poor health, adjusted for research site and mother, child, and household characteristics. Children with severe energy insecurity had greater adjusted odds of household food insecurity, child food insecurity, caregivers reporting significant developmental concerns on the Parents Evaluation of Developmental Status scale, and report of child fair/poor health. No significant association was found between energy security and child weight for age or weight for length.
As household energy insecurity increases, infants and toddlers experienced increased odds of household and child food insecurity and of reported poor health, hospitalizations, and developmental risks.
家庭能源安全尚未通过实证研究进行衡量,也未与儿童健康和发育相关联,但随着能源成本的增加,这已成为临床医生和研究人员日益关注的问题。本研究的目的是制定一项家庭能源安全的临床指标,并评估其与36个月以下儿童的食品安全、健康和发育风险之间的关联。
开展了一项使用家庭调查和监测数据的横断面研究。2001年1月至2006年12月期间,在急诊科和基层医疗诊所对照顾者进行了访谈,内容包括人口统计学、公共援助、食品安全、供暖/制冷及水电使用情况、父母对发育状况的评估以及儿童健康状况。家庭能源安全指标包括能源安全(无能源问题);中度能源不安全(过去一年水电被切断的威胁);以及严重能源不安全(过去一年用炉灶取暖、水电被切断,或有≥1天无供暖/制冷)。主要结局指标包括家庭和儿童食品安全、儿童报告的健康状况、父母对发育状况的评估担忧以及住院情况。
在9721名儿童中,分别有11%(n = 1043)和23%(n = 2293)经历了中度和严重能源不安全。与能源安全的儿童相比,中度能源不安全的儿童出现家庭粮食不安全、儿童粮食不安全、自出生以来住院以及照顾者报告儿童健康状况为一般/较差的几率更高,对研究地点以及母亲、儿童和家庭特征进行了校正。严重能源不安全的儿童在家庭粮食不安全、儿童粮食不安全、照顾者在父母对发育状况的评估量表上报告有显著发育担忧以及报告儿童健康状况为一般/较差方面,经校正后的几率更高。未发现能源安全与儿童年龄别体重或身长别体重之间存在显著关联。
随着家庭能源不安全状况的增加,婴幼儿出现家庭和儿童粮食不安全以及报告健康状况不佳、住院和发育风险增加的几率也会上升。