Fall N, Gröhn Y T, Forslund K, Essen-Gustafsson B, Niskanen R, Emanuelson U
Department of Clinical Sciences, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Uppsala, Sweden.
J Dairy Sci. 2008 Oct;91(10):3983-92. doi: 10.3168/jds.2008-1099.
The aim of this observational study was to compare indicators of energy balance in early lactation in organically managed dairy cows (OMC) and conventionally managed dairy cows (CMC) under field conditions. The diets of OMC and CMC differ as a consequence of the rules and principles of organic dairy farming. The study was based on clinical examinations and blood samples from cows within the range from 2 wk prepartum to 6 wk postpartum, collected from 20 organic and 20 conventional dairy farms with 3 visits at each farm. The farms were located in a southeastern area of Sweden and ranged in size from 45 to 120 cows. The blood parameters selected to reflect energy metabolism were nonesterified fatty acids, beta-hydroxybutyrate, glucose, and insulin. At clinical examination body condition score was registered. The shape of the lactation curve in early lactation was modeled to assess potential differences that could explain the blood parameter profiles. The conventionally managed cows increased their milk yield faster than OMC within the first 2 wk of lactation. Blood nonesterified fatty acid concentrations were similar between the management types, but with a tendency of lesser concentrations in OMC, primarily in early lactation. Postcalving beta-hydroxybutyrate concentrations were constantly lesser in OMC during the first 6 wk of lactation. An interaction between season and insulin concentration necessitated stratification on season. During spring the profiles overlapped, but there was a significant difference in the first 4 d post-calving, when organically managed cows had greater insulin concentrations and in d 30 to 34 when conventionally managed cows had greater insulin concentrations. During fall the profiles overlapped completely and there was no significant difference at any point in time. Glucose concentrations tended to decrease slightly postcalving followed by a gradual elevation to a concentration just under the precalving concentration during the study period. Body condition scores decreased slightly over the study period. No differences were found between the management types with regard to glucose concentrations or registered body condition score. In conclusion, the OMC did not show a greater extent of mobilization of body tissue than CMC as expressed by our study variables. Hence, OMC adjusted the production amount according to feed intake.
本观察性研究的目的是比较在田间条件下,有机管理的奶牛(OMC)和传统管理的奶牛(CMC)在泌乳早期的能量平衡指标。由于有机奶牛养殖的规则和原则,OMC和CMC的日粮有所不同。本研究基于对产前2周至产后6周内奶牛的临床检查和血液样本,这些样本来自20个有机奶牛场和20个传统奶牛场,每个农场进行3次采样。这些农场位于瑞典东南部地区,规模从45头到120头奶牛不等。选择反映能量代谢的血液参数为非酯化脂肪酸、β-羟基丁酸、葡萄糖和胰岛素。在临床检查时记录体况评分。对泌乳早期的泌乳曲线形状进行建模,以评估可能解释血液参数特征的潜在差异。在泌乳的前2周内,传统管理的奶牛比OMC的奶牛产奶量增加得更快。两种管理方式下血液中非酯化脂肪酸浓度相似,但OMC中的浓度有较低的趋势,主要在泌乳早期。产后6周内,OMC产后β-羟基丁酸浓度持续较低。季节与胰岛素浓度之间的相互作用使得需要按季节分层。在春季,曲线重叠,但在产后第1个4天有显著差异,此时有机管理的奶牛胰岛素浓度较高,而在第30至34天,传统管理的奶牛胰岛素浓度较高。在秋季,曲线完全重叠,在任何时间点都没有显著差异。葡萄糖浓度在产后略有下降,随后在研究期间逐渐升高至略低于产前浓度。在研究期间,体况评分略有下降。在葡萄糖浓度或记录的体况评分方面,两种管理方式之间未发现差异。总之,根据我们的研究变量,OMC没有表现出比CMC更大程度的体组织动员。因此,OMC根据采食量调整了产量。