Benouda A, Boujdiya Z, Ahid S, Abouqal R, Adnaoui M
Laboratoire de microbiologie-virologie, hôpital universitaire Cheikh Zaid, avenue Allal El Fassi, Madinat Al Irfane Hay Riyad, Rabat 1100, Maroc.
Pathol Biol (Paris). 2009 Jul;57(5):368-72. doi: 10.1016/j.patbio.2008.07.006. Epub 2008 Oct 7.
This study aims at assessing the prevalence of hepatitis C virus infection (HCV) in Moroccan general population and the efficacy of different virological tests in detection of the viral RNA in order to promote its screening.
From December 1st 2005 to April 30th 2007, the prevalence of the anti-HCV antibodies was determined for 8326 people. The mean age was 42.3+/-11.2 years (18 to 87 years) and sex ratio man/woman: 1.6. The determination of the anti-HCV antibodies in our sample has been achieved by the third generation ELISA. Among the detected cases as anti-HCV negative, 100 have been assessed by two other methods: AxSYM HCV and (Acon HCV): a fast test using immune chromatography on the membrane. Furthermore, the ELISA positive cases, 158 have been tested by the two previous techniques and submitted to viral RNA research by RT-PCR. The detection threshold has been fixed at 50 Ul/ml.
The anti-HCV prevalence determined by ELISA was estimated at 1.93%. The mean age of the positive cases was 50.4 years. The viremia prevalence for positive anti HVC was 39%. The assessment of the methods AxSYM HCV, Acon and PCR compared to ELISA showed that the 100 anti negative VHC cases were also negative for the two other tests. For the 158 anti-VHC positive cases by ELlSA, 100 were also positive by AxSYM HCV, 78 by Acon HCV and 61 were RNA positives. The comparison of the anti-VHC positive results achieved by AxSYM HCV and Acon HCV methods with those related to the presence of viral RNA, showed that the AxSYM HCV method has a sensitivity=100%, a specificity=60%, a positive predictive value=61% and a negative predictive value of 100%. Whereas for the Acon HCV, the sensitivity was 99%, the specificity 87%, the positive predictive value 82% and the predictive negative=100%.
The prevalence of anti-HCV obtained by ELISA has been overestimated. It is necessary to use more specific tests to reduce the risk to announce a false positive result to the patient and to reduce the expenses due to the realization of PCR in case of false positives.
本研究旨在评估摩洛哥普通人群中丙型肝炎病毒感染(HCV)的患病率以及不同病毒学检测在检测病毒RNA方面的效能,以促进其筛查。
从2005年12月1日至2007年4月30日,对8326人进行抗-HCV抗体患病率测定。平均年龄为42.3±11.2岁(18至87岁),男女比例为1.6。我们样本中抗-HCV抗体的测定通过第三代ELISA完成。在检测为抗-HCV阴性的病例中,100例通过另外两种方法进行了评估:AxSYM HCV和(Acon HCV):一种在膜上使用免疫层析的快速检测方法。此外,ELISA阳性的病例中,158例通过上述两种技术进行了检测,并通过RT-PCR进行病毒RNA检测。检测阈值设定为50 Ul/ml。
ELISA测定的抗-HCV患病率估计为1.93%。阳性病例的平均年龄为50.4岁。抗-HCV阳性的病毒血症患病率为39%。与ELISA相比,对AxSYM HCV、Acon和PCR方法的评估显示,100例抗-HCV阴性病例在另外两种检测中也为阴性。对于ELISA检测为抗-HCV阳性的158例病例,AxSYM HCV检测为阳性的有100例,Acon HCV检测为阳性的有78例,RNA阳性的有61例。将AxSYM HCV和Acon HCV方法获得的抗-HCV阳性结果与病毒RNA存在相关结果进行比较,显示AxSYM HCV方法的灵敏度=100%,特异性=60%,阳性预测值=61%,阴性预测值=100%。而对于Acon HCV,灵敏度为99%,特异性为87%,阳性预测值为82%,阴性预测值=100%。
ELISA获得的抗-HCV患病率被高估。有必要使用更特异的检测方法,以降低向患者宣布假阳性结果的风险,并减少因假阳性而进行PCR检测的费用。