Clement Paul W
Am J Psychother. 2008;62(3):215-39. doi: 10.1176/appi.psychotherapy.2008.62.3.215.
Of 1,969 patients seen by a clinical psychologist during 40 years of private practice, at the time the outcome data were analysed 1,374 were either in treatment or had completed treatment and all of these cases had produced outcome data. The results show that four (4) patients (0.29%) became Much Worse, 10 (0.73%) became Worse, 412 (29.96%) showed No Change, 467 (33.96%) became Better, and 482 (35.06%) were Much Better. The mean treatment effect size (ES) was 1.87. Outcome varied significantly across diagnostic categories. Outcome also varied by age groups. Outcome for males and females did not differ, but both kinds of individual patients did better than when couples were the focus of treatment. The dropout rate was 17%. The mean number of sessions per case was 17.43, the median was 10, and the range was 1 to 344. There was a significant positive correlation between number of treatment sessions and outcome. The therapist's effectiveness did not improve across the years. Managed care had a significant negative impact on treatment outcomes.
在一位临床心理学家40年的私人执业生涯中,共接待了1969名患者。在分析结果数据时,其中1374名患者正在接受治疗或已经完成治疗,所有这些病例都产生了结果数据。结果显示,4名(0.29%)患者病情恶化,10名(0.73%)患者病情变差,412名(29.96%)患者无变化,467名(33.96%)患者病情好转,482名(35.06%)患者病情显著好转。平均治疗效果量(ES)为1.87。不同诊断类别之间的结果差异显著。结果也因年龄组而异。男性和女性的结果没有差异,但这两种个体患者的治疗效果都比以夫妻为治疗重点时更好。脱落率为17%。每个病例的平均治疗次数为17.43次,中位数为10次,范围为1至344次。治疗次数与结果之间存在显著的正相关。多年来治疗师的治疗效果没有提高。管理式医疗对治疗结果有显著的负面影响。